Gentle nudge on this thread... Could I please get some feedback? Is there agreement or disagreement with the changes I'm proposing for the Yetus JIRA permissions?
Assuming there is agreement, Sean, does being listed as the project lead in JIRA give you the super-powers to do this, or shall I proceed with filing an INFRA JIRA? Thanks! --Chris Nauroth On 10/17/15, 2:39 PM, "Chris Nauroth" <[email protected]> wrote: >Thanks for the further details, Kengo. > >For 1, I think this means that we want to give Contributors the Transition >Issues permission. > >For 2, I think this means that we want to give Contributors the Assign >Issues permission. > >Right now, Yetus is using the default JIRA permission scheme. One way to >solve this would be to change Yetus to use the "Hadoop Permissions" >scheme, which already does the above. Another way to solve it would be to >branch off and create our own permissions scheme just for Yetus. > >Sean, do you have the ability to switch permissions schemes due to any >super-powers you get from having the project Lead role in JIRA? If not, >then I'll file the INFRA JIRA. I'd suggest that we go ahead and request >our own Yetus permission scheme instead of using Hadoop's. > >I can include the request for the release note field at the same time. > >--Chris Nauroth > > > > >On 10/17/15, 12:42 AM, "Kengo Seki" <[email protected]> wrote: > >>Thanks for picking up my comment and investigation. >>There are two problems, and both of them are not resolved at the time of >>writing. >> >>1. On the issues which I didn't file, "Submit Patch" and "Resolve Issue" >>buttons are not shown. >>2. On any issues, I can't assign myself to them. >> >> >>2015-10-17 4:56 GMT+09:00 Chris Nauroth <[email protected]>: >> >>> I was about to file an INFRA JIRA, but I took a closer look, and I'm >>>not >>> sure we really have a problem. >>> >>> jira-users is in the Contributors role. >>> >>> >>>https://issues.apache.org/jira/plugins/servlet/project-config/YETUS/role >>>s >>> >>> >>> Members of the Contributors role may be assigned issues. >>> >>> >>>https://issues.apache.org/jira/plugins/servlet/project-config/YETUS/perm >>>i >>>ss >>> ions >>> >>> >>> However, note that Contributors does not have the "Assign Issues" >>> permission, so they can't assign issues to anyone. Maybe that is the >>> problem Kengo reported? >>> >>> I did some basic testing and verified that multiple people who are not >>> Yetus committers can be the assignee on a YETUS issue. >>> >>> Do we think this is OK now, or did I misunderstand the problem? >>> >>> We'd still need to request the release note field. >>> >>> --Chris Nauroth >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> On 10/15/15, 9:56 AM, "Allen Wittenauer" <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>> > >>> >On Oct 15, 2015, at 9:29 AM, Chris Nauroth <[email protected]> >>> >wrote: >>> >> >>> >> If it's not working for us, then shall we file an INFRA JIRA? >>> > >>> > >>> >While we¹re talking to infra about JIRA, I¹d really like to have the >>> >release note field tooŠ esp since releasedocmaker supports it. :) >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> >>> >
