On Mar 24, 2010, at 02:46:23, Felipe Contreras wrote:
This would fit my finding that nobody has _ever_ filed a but report for Yahoo contacts in MSN:
http://trac.adium.im/query?status=assigned&status=closed&status=new&status=pending&component=Service/MSN&summary=~yahoo

Not on Trac, but I found three requests for it in my Adium feedback archives (I stopped looking in mid-2008; the feature debuted on the service in 2005). There may also have been requests on it in comments on our blog and on our IRC channels. It's not a deafening clamor, but it's not *nobody*.

I do believe you're right, though, that far more people have asked *us* for direct file transfers than have asked to be able to add Yahoo! contacts to their MSN account.

If Adium does currently support that, then that's a different story: As previously stated, it would be a feature regression to remove it, and we'd have to decide whether we want to trade one feature for the other (policy says no). However, if Adium currently does not support it, then we can get away with the switch.

To clarify one possible case: The feature may be working in Libpurple and working in Pidgin but somehow broken in Adium. I don't care. If that's the case, then whether the code is there or not, to the user's eyes, it isn't. We wouldn't be taking away something they already have (which is to say, can use).

So, is anyone able to chat with Yahoo! contacts using their MSN account in Adium?


Reply via email to