Michiel Meeuwissen wrote:
> Martijn Houtman wrote: > > Thanks, so it seems not very handy to have a separate committers list. > > > No. The committer list is for issues we would formally direct to the MMC. > This was a request to 'reopen' a project, which I figured would be such an > issue. > > > > I did some research and also considered Kupu. I have the impression that > > FCKEditor is more promising. I tried out for both the JavaScript version. If > > I look at the source text in Kupu it appears to be HTML and not XHTML. Kupu > > does change every tag to capitals, which is not valid XHTML, while FCKEditor > > does it right, it does even change the <P> tags inserted by hand in the > > source to <p>. Furthermore, it seems that FCKEditor has more editing > > possibilities. > > I did not notice that Kupu produced capitals, it doesn't as far as I know. > > > > May be someone can give me a reason why Kupu is a better choice? What I > > understand is that the developers are more CMS oriented and Kupu is used in > > Wiki and Plone sites, but I see also that Plone and Wiki sites currently are > > implementing FCKEditor. > > I liked kupu becacuse of the extensibility and I could sufficently easily > switch off features, and most importantly it has 'drawers'. The most > important thing I searched for is the possibility to make in-text links to > mmbase objects. I don't want feature bloat, and more editing > possibilities. Smileys, colors, forms, buttons, skins, etc, I'd prefer not to have > in an editor, at least not for now.. > > But I did not look into fckeditor into much detail yet, I needed something > what would do the job, and kupu seemed helpful, and used in several other > CMS's already. > Thanks for you explanation. Another thing I noticed is that Kupu is more Linux oriented and FCKEditor more Windows oriented, which may introduce a bias in preferences :-). It might be that Kupu transforms to XHTML lateron and the result differs from what you see in the source, but I noticed some complaints about generating invalid XHTML in the newsgroups. A problem with FCKEditor could be that it contains so many possibilities, including the possibility for bugs... Martijn Houtman _______________________________________________ Developers mailing list [email protected] http://lists.mmbase.org/mailman/listinfo/developers
