The discussion of tags and their interpretation is entirely different to the main problem, there are too many developers here who are missing the other, and more important problem: usability.
Please, please, please can the issue of which tags, which version of tags etc but put aside for one thread. Can you please consider the users' perspective we don't care if the tag is Band, AlbumArtist or what ever. That is the angels on a pinhead issue. You are missing the mote in your eye: The fact remains that stated way of working: -if the album is natural compilation multiple authors and there is album artist it is listed under album artist. Irrespective of whether this is Band tag, ALBUMARTIST it doesn't matter, because this functionality is still broken! Such an Album is still found under: Home->Artists->Various Artists (albeit listed as by the album artist). And it is not listed under Home->Artists->album artist. Where it is wanted. For example: My Favourite Band, creates an album called "Debut", all tracks are by "My Favourite Band", the album by "My Favourite Band", but the last track they are joined by "Guest Artist" Currently album "Debut" is listed as being by "My Favourite Band". But because of the last track this album is found under "Home->Artists->Various Artists" - it's listed as "Debut" by "My Favourite Band" - but it's in the wrong place. If I navigate to "Home->Artists->My Favourite Band" album "Debut" is not there. This is the real problem, not the internal representation of the band's name. -- bullgod ------------------------------------------------------------------------ bullgod's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=9916 View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=46093 _______________________________________________ discuss mailing list [email protected] http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/discuss
