> Sent: Saturday, October 12, 2019 at 9:11 PM > From: "Dmitry Alexandrov" <[email protected]> > To: "Aaron Wolf" <[email protected]> > Cc: [email protected] > Subject: Re: “should have had a warning / apology” > > Aaron Wolf <[email protected]> wrote: > > On 2019-10-12 10:13 a.m., Dmitry Alexandrov wrote: > >> Aaron Wolf <[email protected]> wrote: > >>> On 2019-10-12 3:20 a.m., Dmitry Alexandrov wrote: > >>>> Aaron Wolf <[email protected]> wrote: > >>>>> MBR posted a Facebook link (which should have had a warning/apology > >>>>> perhaps) > >>>> > >>>> I beg my pardon? Warning of / apology for what? > >>> > >>> Just like "sorry for Facebook link" or something (because Facebook is a > >>> company that works against most of the values we care about here). > >> > >> Well, a good half of the Internet work against or at least contributes > >> something against freedom of computing. I do not think that _we_ have to > >> apologize for them. > >> > >>> I checked just now that this particular link is visible publicly without > >>> JavaScript though, so I guess it's not too bad, relatively speaking. > >> > >> Basically, it is not bad at all. :-) > >> > >> But do you mean, that Facebook have other pages that are not readable > >> without running nonfree scripts? > > > > Unlike Twitter, it can be common to have Facebook links that people assume > > are basically public and visible but get blocked by requirement to sign-in. > > Aha, thanks. > > > I'm not sure about the Javascript issues per se. > > > > And I generally do apologies (and promote such habits) when I use or prompt > > others to engage with entities I feel are harmful overall. To be specific > > to software freedom, instead of an absolute of never suggesting or using > > any proprietary software ever, I make compromises to be practical but I > > *acknowledge* and *apologize* for them. They aren't my fault, but I'm > > promoting *awareness* of the problem and refusing to spread the idea that > > using non-free software is just fine and normal. > > I don’t believe, that saying ‘sorry for Facebook link’ would raise awareness > of computing freedom. If a person is not aware of free software, he’d rather > accredit it to something else or just ignore it than wonder or ask you about > true reasons. (Few years ago it was common in Runet to apologize for links > to livejournal.com for the reasons not quite apparent even to those who did > it, it was just a tradition). > > It is felt, that it’d be much better to actually suggest a solution, if any > exists. For instance, speaking of twitter.com, which is normally unusable > without nonfree software¹, use mobile.twitter.com links instead. Link to > some js-full page through web.archive.org or archive.is, which often helps > (though it’s basically using them as a scapegoat). Suggest to use > mpv+youtube-dl / weboob / minitube / NewPipe for viewing a youtube.com link. > Suggest to set ‘User-Agent’ to that of Googlebot to avoid consentwall like on > yahoo.com²; etc. > > > ¹ twitter.com actually has that silly type of interface that is loaded almost > fully readable without any scripts but shadowed — and might be revealed with > an adblocker. > > ² If you do not see any consentwall there, you are fortunate enough to be in > GDPR-free country.
Thank you for your insight, Dmitry. I like it. -- Best regards, Eus _______________________________________________ Discussion mailing list [email protected] https://lists.fsfellowship.eu/mailman/listinfo/discussion
