> Standardize?
> 
> Apparently, you haven't read the well known address proposal.
> 
>                                               Masataka Ohta

        to reiterate my concerns expressed at the mic yesterday,
        
        Ohta-san, would you be comfortable with 200,000,000 devices
        being shipped with the IP address 131.112.32.188 (the address
        of one of your organizations nameservers) being burned into
        eeprom?

        disclaimers about restricting, by IETF fiat, well known addresses
        to special IP ranges will -NOT- work in the real world.

        If you are willing to commit your enterprise to absorb 0.1%
        of the total packets generated by 200,000,000 devices, then 
        perhaps I will be persuaded that use of well-known addresses
        is an operationally acceptable technique.  

        Yes, I know we do it now and it reduces the level of effort
        in getting new features deployed, but in -EVERY- case, the
        use of well known addresses has caused problems.

--bill
#----------------------------------------------------------------------
# To unsubscribe, send a message to <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>.

Reply via email to