On Tue, Nov 16, 2010 at 06:07:28AM +0900, Masataka Ohta wrote: > IT'S ENOUGH THAT YOU ADMIT "IT DEPENDS". Remember that you wrote > "Because the matching function can not be changed." in your > mail on November 13.
It seems to me that screaming on the list and taking two different phrases out of context and mashing them together is a demonstration that you are not interested in good faith conversations. Moreover, > And, under ISO 8859/1, it does not even depend, ISO 8859-1 is completely irrelevant here, because how you get to the point of having a U-label is totally out of scope for the IDNA2008 specification. But whatever you do to get to that point, the U-label has nothing whatever to do with ISO 8859-1. > Then, we have agreed that localized domain names in IDNA2008 can > not handle case insensitivities. It is certainly true that the DNS-protocol case preservation but case insensitivity matching rules are not internationalized exactly as one might like in IDNA2008. Without DNSng, I have no idea how to solve that. But you seem to be willfully ignoring that IDNA2008 actually does address this, although in an uncomfortable and somewhat unsatisfying way. One could be forgiven for imagining that you haven't bothered to read the RFCs you are insisting don't address the issue you're talking about. The draft does not need to address this point, because the point is addressed elsewhere. Every draft on internationlization is not an opportunity to re-explore the rathole down which the IDNABIS working group laboured for several years. IDNA is shipping. All the current draft does is permit TLDs that are in conformance with IDNA2008, except that it attempts to make the change as small as possible in order to try to minimise the possibility of surprises from software that had understood RFC 1123 as protocol and not policy. I think the document should be shipped as soon as possible. A -- Andrew Sullivan [email protected] Shinkuro, Inc. _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
