Klaus Malorny wrote:
>>> Sure, but I am talking of about 5-20 variants per name, not all that are
>>> combinatorially possible.
> The idea is that the registrant simply decides which of the variants he
> wants to have included with his original name. Those would be added to
> the zone via redirection resource records, whatever available. When he
> reaches a registry given limit, he has to make a trade-off, which of the
> possible variants he regards as most valuable for his purpose. From my
> perspective, this is an acceptable compromise.
OK. If it is acceptable for you, allow 1 variant per name and we
are done.
That people around you are happy with at most 5 or 20 variants
does not mean other people needing more variants may suffer
from the trade-off.
A better solution is never use IDN. That, even within European
(French) context, capital form of 'y' with diaeresis can be 'Y'
or 'Y' with diaeresis is already bad enough for case insensitive
DNS.
Masataka Ohta
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
