>>>> The problem is that your router replaces the public IP address Ekiga >>>> puts in by a private one due to a bug in the router itself, you can see >>>> the Ekiga PDUs in the log, they are correct. >>>> If you disable STUN, perhaps your router will put the public IP address >>>> in the packets. >>>> >>>> What happens is that some dummy routers replace public ip's by private >>>> ones. That's your case. >>> >>> Don't think that's true. As I said, using twinkle behind the NAT with the >>> same router works perfectly with that provider. So the router couldn't be >>> the problem here and it seems that it's indeed a software issue. >> >> Please show me a trace of Ekiga with stun disabled and a trace of >> twinkle so that we can compare both. >> >> Btw, I don't understand your reasoning which consists to say that Ekiga >> puts deliberately private IP addresses in PDUs when the log says no. > > Again, to clearify my reasoning, these are the relevant observations: > > Firstly: > Relevant -d 4 output of ekiga says the following when trying to connect to > bluesip.net: > > rem=udp$217.74.179.29:5060,local=udp$96.232.27.238:5060,if=192.168.1.36%wlan0 > SIP/2.0 479 Please don't use private IP addresses > > This suggests that there's a problem with the private IP address > (192.168.1.36). Whether this is sip conform or not I dodn't know. Concerning > to some people in some voip forums, it isn't. > > Secondly: > This behavior is independent of using a STUN server or not and only appears > when I am behind a NAT router. > > And thirdly: > The fact that twinkle is able to connect to bluesip successfully from behind > this specific router, suggests that this is no router-issue.
This issue sounds quite familiar to a couple of bugs I've had reported on F-11 where they are unable to connect to a SIP server where with previous versions of ekiga they were (in some cases they even went as far as recompiling ekiga 2 themselves. Peter _______________________________________________ Ekiga-devel-list mailing list Ekiga-devel-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-devel-list
