Hallo,

it seems to me that Score DSV does not satisfy
monotonicity. It seems to me that the following
scenario is possible:

   Candidate A is the original winner.

   Suppose some voters rank candidate A higher
   without changing the order in which they
   rank the other candidates relatively to
   each other. Then it is possible that some
   other candidate B is kicked out of the Smith
   set and that, after renormalizing the ballots,
   candidate A is worse off.

Markus Schulze


----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info

Reply via email to