Hello,
--- En date de : Sam 29.8.09, Jameson Quinn <[email protected]> a écrit :
> I expect that Score DSV will have lower Bayesian Regret
> than any other system, even score (aka range) voting, given
> voters with any reasonable amount of non-false information
> making a rational choice of strategies, with any given
> (ideologically-biased or -unbiased) mix of minimum
> expected-benefit thresholds for voting strategically rather
> than honestly, as long as at least half of voters have an
> "attainable" strategic threshold.
I don't see why you would guess that Score DSV would have better
Bayesian Regret than Range. It looks like you tried to make a method that
helps a voter get the best result for himself, which isn't the same as
getting the best result overall.
Warren defines BR in such a way that Range is unbeatable given sincere
votes.
If he measured your method, admitting strategic votes, he would make
strategy assumptions that would make it look terrible.
Your wiki page seems to be lacking some proofs.
Kevin Venzke
----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
