At 07:36 PM 3/8/2012, Kevin Venzke wrote:
Hi Mike,
I don't think Approval-Runoff can get off the ground since it's too
apparent that a party could nominate two candidates (signaling that one
is just a pawn to aid the other) and try to win by grabbing both of the
finalist positions. If this happened regularly it would be just an
expensive version of FPP.
Number one. This objection does not apply to nonpartisan elections.
Number two. The strongest factor in elections is positive name
recognition. That's become obvious. By running two candidates, you
are diluting name recognition. If you have one, you might win. With
two, quite possibly not. Risky strategy.
Number three. The strategy assumes that there will be no rivalry
between the two candidates. Even if they are in cahoots, their
supporters may not be.
Number four. Who gets the campaign funds?
Number five. Others can play the same game, if it's a real strategy.
I don't think it is.
Number six. If this is a partisan election, who gets the party slot?
The strategy could badly backfire, as supporters of the non-party
candidate decide not to support the official party candidate, after
all, the party made a bad choice. No, the tradition is strong, and
there are strong reasons for it, that a party unites on a candidate.
It's more powerful.
Number seven. If both candidates make it into the runoff, very good
chance one of them would win anyway. This means that they are top
two, really. If this is nonpartisan, very difficult to reverse that.
Number eight. You might be able to figure out a scenario where this
makes some sense.
Now, compare that scenario with the real and known hazard of center squeeze.
Besides, once we are Counting All the Votes, a ranked version of
approval becomes far better.
SODA actually does allow you to not delegate via checking a box. But
a version that required delegation might be interesting because it
wouldn't require an "approval plus checkbox" ballot, it would just need
a vote-for-one ballot.
My preference, in fact. This is the simplest way to implement Asset.
----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
