Good Morning, Peter
re: "In your list, you forgot to mention 'campaign spending by
third parties' ..."
Goal (2) was intended to cover this problem, but is poorly worded. We
should examine the corrosive effect of political campaigning more
carefully and then improve the statement of the goal.
Campaigning is a one-way process. It is a flow of assertions from
politicians to the people. It benefits the politicians but provides no
benefit to the people because they cannot examine the campaigners. Even
when they know the assertions are false or misleading, they have no way
to examine the source to determine the truth.
Political campaigning makes conventional democratic systems susceptible
to financial influence. Businesses, labor unions and other vested
interests give immense amounts of money and logistical support to
political parties to push their agenda and to secure the passage of laws
that benefit the donors. The result is a cesspool of corruption, funded
by special interests that buy the laws we endure.
In addition to the inherently corruptive nature of begging for money to
finance political campaigns, the high cost creates an artificial barrier
that prevents competitive ideas from challenging the dominant parties.
Perhaps the least acknowledged aspect of political campaigning is its
devastating effect on the character of the candidates. When
campaigning, politicians use ideas and arguments, not to search for
truth, but to manipulate the people in the quest for power. They pursue
that power through whatever means they think most effective, without
regard for right and wrong. For them, campaigning is a training course
in the art of deception.
To make matters worse, candidates are incessantly lionized by their
supporters. These things have a debilitating effect on the candidate's
character, and, since morality is a top-down phenomenon, choosing
political leaders by this method elevates amoral or immoral candidates
and destroys society. If we wish to improve our culture, we must
acknowledge the adverse effects of campaign-based politics and conceive
a better way to select our political leaders.
Goal (2) should be modified to reflect this reality.
I started a comment on your reference to 'media coverage' but it turns
out to be a fairly complex matter so I'll do some more work on it and
post it when I've finished.
Fred
----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
