On 13.07.2012 19:52 meekerdb said the following:
On 7/13/2012 10:22 AM, Evgenii Rudnyi wrote:
On 12.07.2012 22:08 meekerdb said the following:
In Dennett's conception 'free will' is just a marker for
responsibility; hence his aphorism, "You can avoid responsibility
for everything if you just make yourself small enough." So where
one person might say, "Yes, it was me. I did it." another might
say, "I didn't do it of my own free will. I was coerced by
threats of being fired." and yet another might say, "I didn't do
it. It was just the result of deterministic or random physical
processes in my brain and body."
The question then would be what determines what a person say.
You mistake the point. Dennet's aphorism is a reductio ad absurdum -
illustrating how ridiculous is is try to avoid responsibility by
blaming physical processes.
Does unpredictability that you have mentioned in another message
will help in this respect? If yes, how?
If you're asking whether unpredictability eliminates responsibility,
the answer is no.
My question would be not about responsibility, I am not that far. Let us
take a chess game (the example from John). We have two people playing
chess and then for example the M-theory.
How would you characterize the relationship between the M-theory and
players. In what sense it is possible to say that the players play their
own game? How unpredictability would help here?
You have mentioned the chaos theory when you have written about
predictability. Frankly speaking I do not understand the point, the
chaos theory claims. If I understand correctly, it basically says that
the uncertainty in the initial condition brings unpredictability. Yet, I
do not understand where the uncertainty in initial conditions come from.
If we discuss things in principle, then we should consider the case when
the initial conditions are known exactly.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at