Vaj wrote:
> ...yoga-darshana's traditional culmination is turiyatita 
> or Cosmic Consciousness in TM parlance (in some contexts 
> referred to as jivan-mukta). 
>
The culmination of yoga-darshana is *isolation* (kaivalya).
There's no "turiyatita" in the Yoga Darshana; that term is
from Gaudapadacharya, the first expositor of Adwaita.

The tern "jivan-mukta" is also from Adwaita and is not used
in the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali.

> In schools which use a yogic and tantric approach to  
> the advaita View (of reality) one will see a first stage 
> of turiyatita which then culminates in videha-mukti or 
> Brahma-cetana (Unity Consciousness). Mahesh's main 
> innovation (or deviation depending on your POV) is GC,
> bhagavata-cetana, which is the traditional enlightenment 
> state of devotional, bhakti yogins.
>
There is no notion of "enlightenment" in the devotional 
sects - individuals who follow the bhakti path don't
even aspire to enlightenment - their goal is seva and
devotion to a Personal God, not liberation from God
"while yet living". Bhaktas aspire to Brahma-loka when 
they die.   

> These are all covered in the Badarayana sutra and it's 
> various commentaries.
>
There is no mention of "bhakti" in the work of Badarayana.
The bhakti sects came much later, during the Gupta or
Golden Age of Hinduism. 
 
> In fact, this is where Mahesh got the idea for seven 
> states of consciousness.
>
In fact, the notion of "seven states of conciousness" comes 
from the Nath Siddhas and Kundalini Yoga propounded by 
Matsyendranath - seven chakras.
 
> There is a rare tape where Mahesh does discuss a seven 
> chakra system.
>
Maybe so, but if you are mistaken about the facts of Indian
history you may be mistaken about this as well. 

Titles of interest:

'An Introduction to Hinduism' 
by Gavin D. Flood
Cambridge University Press, 1996

'The New Cambridge History of India'
by Burton Stein 
Cambridge University Press, 1990

'A New History of India' 
by Stanley Wolpert
Oxford University Press, 2003

'A History of India: Volume 1' 
by Romila Thapar
Penguin Classics, 1990 

'Cultural History of India'
by A. L. Basham
Oxford University Press, 1999

Reply via email to