Andrew Stiller wrote:

I wished we had more politics like in France protecting many hundred years of German culture.


Johannes


Yeah, well there are lots of folks here who think that American culture is threatened by the Spanish language. I don't think much of that reasoning no matter where it comes from.


We have an American culture? (said with tongue in cheek) After Johannes' post I was thinking "Gee, I wish we *had* a culture which we could protect!"

The American culture has never been monolithic and I don't see the Spanish language threatening what has never existed.

I do see it as threatening American citizens' ability to communicate effectively with each other, and I fear that when a country's citizens can no longer effectively communicate with each other, the ability to function as a country is threatened.

But a threat to American culture? The culture which has absorbed and included aspects at and contributions from, even while some Americans looked down their noses at, Irish and Italian and French and German and Moravian and Bohemian and Russian and Jewish and various African and Chinese and Japanese and Spanish cultures as well as the cultures of the peoples that the Europeans displaced? If anybody can define American culture in as succinct a manner as they can define French or German or British culture, I will be amazed.

--
David H. Bailey
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to