At 1:11 PM +0200 5/2/08, Johannes Gebauer wrote:
I have sort of lost touch with this discussion, but I remember that there are theories that Bach wrote the 4th Brandenburg concerto for recorder instruments not in F but in G. Can anyone here shed some light on this for me? Would such instruments have been built for a pitch of 415 Hz?
They could have and would have been made for any pitch they were ordered at, which is to say whatever the pitch standard was at Köthen, so that isn't a factor. And of course the standard relative pitch of alto woodwinds in the renaissance was G rather than F, so the idea would not have been anything new.
The argument (to which I adhere) hinges on the fact that the high F# is difficult to produce on most alto recorders and impossible on some. Using a modern Dolmetsch at 440, the only way I can produce it is to close the bottom of the tube against my thigh, which not only looks passing strange but puts one's lips and teeth in jeopardy at the tempo of the first movement!
So, against that background, the fact is that the 1st recorder part goes merrily on its way up the scale to the high G, passing through the F# on the way up and the way down. Simple and easy on a G alto, and the 1st part does not go too low for a G alto. The 2nd recorder part, however, imitates the 1st until it reaches that F# and then turns back on itself without attempting it, strongly suggesting to me that it was written for an F alto.
That internal proof is all the proof we will ever have, since Bach did not notate woodwind parts as transposing instruments, but I find it quite convincing. And again, that is recorders in G and F relative to the pitch used at Köthen, which may have been Kammerton or tiefe Kammerton or something else entirely. The modern idea of "baroque pitch" being at 415 is simply a modern convenience since it is approximately a half-step shift for a harpsichord keyboard, but that was only one of many "non-standard standard pitches" that would have been found across Europe.
John -- John R. Howell, Assoc. Prof. of Music Virginia Tech Department of Music College of Liberal Arts & Human Sciences Blacksburg, Virginia, U.S.A. 24061-0240 Vox (540) 231-8411 Fax (540) 231-5034 (mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]) http://www.music.vt.edu/faculty/howell/howell.html _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [email protected] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
