Glancing through Jari's review, what catches my attention is the modification 
of the Staff Usage dialog box, since I use that dialog routinely (which I 
gather most users don't).

Showing the staff label instead of just the number is nice. I also can see why 
they've altered the input so that you enter the difference between the staff's 
position and the previous staff's position. That way if you need to add space 
between the top two staves, it automatically bumps the rest down by the same 
amount. Most of my music is piano-vocal, so I've only got three staves anyway, 
but I can see how it would save even more time in a full score.

What I very much DON'T like, if I'm reading the dialog box illustration on 
Jari's page correctly, is that the distance from the top staff now is not 
displayed at all. Even if the input is for distance between systems, can't they 
still display the total distance somewhere in the window so I still have it as 
reference? This is a downgrade for me because I use that number. As I've 
mentioned, I edit Staff Usage for pretty much every system in every piece I do 
(and if I don't edit, it's because I've made a conscious decision to leave it 
where it is, in which case I still know the position). Seeing the distance of 
the bottom staff in each system tells me how much vertical space I'm using up 
within the systems, so I know how much space I have remaining to fill in 
between systems. Without that number, I've got to add the two staff-to-staff 
numbers. My standard work is piano-vocal with four systems on a page, so that's 
the difference between four numbers and eight numbers, which is pretty much the 
difference between keeping track in my head or breaking out the calculator for 
every page.

This is one more in a long line of changes that make the program more 
user-friendly for most users but less convenient for detail-oriented 
control-freaks like me.  In the larger scheme of things it’s pretty minor, but 
it seems so unnecessary. For one thing, if anything ought to be tailored to 
users like me, surely it’s this dialog box. I use it all the time, but when it 
came up on the list a few weeks ago I got the impression many users didn’t even 
know it exists. I figure the rest of you just drag your staves around anyway, 
right? More important, I’m not even objecting to the basic UI changes. I think 
those are fine. I’m just mad that they have removed useful information. Why 
can’t they update the UI and leave the information still there for those of us 
who make use of it? Is it really that important to make the window look less 
cluttered for everyone else?

I don’t expect to upgrade to v2001 anyway, but I’m curious. Where else do you 
go when you want to see exactly how tall a system is?  I’m used to finding this 
in Staff Usage for the bottom staff because that's a familiar dialog box for 
me. Is it displayed somewhere else that I’m not thinking of?

mdl

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to