On 4 Jun 2010 at 12:23, Mark D Lew wrote:

> This is one more in a long line of changes that make the program more
> user-friendly for most users but less convenient for detail-oriented
> control-freaks like me.

For me, personally, that change is a huge help. I NEVER need to know 
the distance from the top staff (though the way you describe your 
usage of it, I might well have been better off paying attention to 
it).

I don't drag staves -- I manually calculate the distance from the top 
staff for each stave. Well, to be more specific, I drag to a general 
location, then fix the spacing by calculating. For instance, I 
started a new score last night, 2 sopranos, 5 viols, and a 2-staff 
basso continuo. I actually started this one by copying an existing 
score, but if I were creating it from scratch, I'd set things by eye, 
then use manual calculations to figure the proper distance between 
the viol staves (which should all be equal). To do that, I'd set the 
top staff by eye, then the bottom staff by eye, then figure out what 
the distance should be between the intervening staves.

Even the new system doesn't really change this, it just makes the 
calculations easier.

There really ought to be a feature where you select a number of 
contiguous staves and tell Finale to space them evenly vertically. Or 
maybe a setting for a staff group, where you could set the inter-
group spacing, so you could change that one number and change the 
whole group at once.

These are the things that I think would make things a lot easier, 
whereas the change you are complaining about is really quite 
incremental. It makes the older task somewhat easier for most of us, 
but it's still the WRONG task!

I also don't see why one shouldn't have the option to display either 
the between-staff distance or the distance from the top staff. It 
could default to the new setting. Being able to flip back and forth 
between the two measurements would be quite useful, I'd think.

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to