Thanks for that thoughtful answer. It sounds like the workaround is even more difficult than I had imagined.

Basically I am calling "shenanigans" on the concept of Finale as a realistic rendering platform. They are 90% towards a fantastic solution, but that last 10% makes it practically useless.

It all comes down to the time it takes to get the job done. For this score (2 minutes 25 instruments) it took me about 2 hours to get a marginally passable rendering. To be fair, about half of that time was caused by two bugs -- one that crashed Finale any time I tried to start playback from other than measure 1, and another one where tempotap refused to respect my clicks on certain measures -- I had to delete those measures and re-enter them from scratch.

If I were to try to get the mix just right on this score (assuming I didn't have the above bugs), I think it would have taken another 2 hours of painstakingly going through the the score measure by measure adjusting either the dynamic markings or the MIDI data. Let's call that a 3 hour project total.

If I could hit a button and create separate WAV files, I would have done about 30 minutes of editing in Finale. And mixing the whole job perfectly in Audacity would not have taken another 30 minutes. Worst case, that job takes an hour and produces a better result.

If I dump out MIDI tracks and run them into Cubase (assuming I have all the right instruments available in Cubase), there is going to be a lengthy setup time just to get the instruments assigned properly. I'm thinking that would be a 2-hour job if I were a real Cubase genius, which I'm not.

The upshot is that for Finale to be taken serious as a rendering tool, it needs to either produce independent WAV files per track or else become an order of magnitude easier to achieve a reasonable mix.

My 2 cents.


On 6/6/2010 1:25 AM, Randolph Peters wrote:
You have guessed correctly. There are no good short cuts to getting separate 
WAV tracks.

You should solo just the track (or tracks) you want in the Instrument List 
window in order to make WAV files and then combine them in Audacity or 
whatever. Just be aware that if Human Playback is involved, you will get small 
but deadly timing variations between takes, so you will want to apply Human 
Playback to the file as a permanent modification. You then turn off HP and each 
track will then follow the same tempo variations. You could do this to a copy 
of the original file in case you don't like the results.

Don't forget to record a click intro on each take so as to more easily align 
your tracks. They won't all start at exactly the same place.

Even with the fastest computer and the most efficient use of instrument 
resources, Finale does not have the same precision as a dedicated sequencing 
program such as Cubase, Logic or Digital Performer.

MakeMusic will tell you to port the MIDI file to those sequencer programs if 
you really want to control the audio aspect, but there are problems with that 
route:

i) the MIDI file often has hung notes, and strange Human Playback artifacts,

ii) you will get more MIDI tracks than staves for reasons that aren't 
consistent,

iii) the Garritan sounds that come with Finale (after version 2007 anyways) 
don't load into those sequencer programs because of the way they are licensed. 
You will need the full Garritan program or other 3rd party sample files and 
they will probably use different key switches and other controllers. This user 
limitation is a major PITA if you port to a sequencing program a lot.

-Randolph Peters

P.S. It might be theoretically possible to route each track to a corresponding 
track in a dedicated sequencer, but you run into computer limitations with this 
many tracks as well some of the same issues I mentioned above.


_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to