Vincent, Jeremias, thanks for the clarification.
After looking just a little bit more into it it appears the current fop version is dealing pretty badly with inline borders and padding. There seem to be no testcases for it either. I'll attach 2 files. A simple test case. The pdf output from that as produced by the current trunk version. The output is wrong on a number of points. 1. The border / padding is overlapping with the text 2. The top/bottom border / padding should be outside the allocation rectangle for the fo:inline and therefore extend above and below the enclosing block. 3. There is a strange gap between the fo:inline and the following text. I suspect it has to do with some piece of code using the correct allocation rectangle and others not. Not sure if I am up to fixing this as that may go into the depth of the Knuth boxes etc.. But if someone if prepared to give me some pointers on where to start I'll be prepared to give it a go. Manuel On Fri, 2 Sep 2005 01:04 am, Jeremias Maerki wrote: > Oh right. Again someone caught me shooting too fast from the hip. > Damn. I will probably never manage to get that right. :-( It's good > to have people around to pay attention. > > I wondered about the large-allocation-rectangle while reading through > 6.3.2 but obviously forgot to check the docs for e-g and i-f-o. > Sorry, Manuel, Vincent is right. > > On 01.09.2005 18:44:52 Vincent Hennebert wrote: > > I'm not sure here. The fo:external-graphic uses the > > large-allocation-rectangle (§ 6.6.5), that comprises padding and > > border. This makes me say that in Manuel's example the fo:block's > > bpd should be calculated with the second formula. The fo:block's > > content forms a line whose line-stacking-strategy is max-height > > (default). Thus its allocation rectangle should comprise the > > image's border & padding (§ 4.5). And so does the block. > > > > I may be wrong, as this part of the spec is still somewhat unclear > > to me. WDYT? > > > > Vincent > > > > Jeremias Maerki a écrit : > > > Indeed, the normal allocation rectangle of an inline area is > > > different than the one of a block area. See 4.3.2. Geometric > > > Definitions in the 1.0 spec. > > > > > > Border and padding for an inline area seem to be outside the > > > allocation rectangle in before and after directions. Interesting. > > > > > > On 01.09.2005 17:29:50 Manuel Mall wrote: > > >>I have a follow-up question on this. If we have something as > > >> simple(?) as this: > > >> > > >><fo:block background-color="orange"> > > >> <fo:external-graphic > > >> src="../../resources/images/bgimg300dpi.jpg" > > >> border="solid 5pt" > > >> padding="5pt" > > >> background-color="white"/> > > >></fo:block> > > >> > > >>would you expect the whole image including padding and borders to > > >> be within the bounds of the enclosing block or only the actual > > >> image to be in the block and the padding and borders to "stick > > >> out" at the top and bottom. It seems xep takes the latter > > >> approach and I am very uncertain in this area. Or to put it > > >> differently is the BPD of the enclosing block > > >> bpd = image height + line-spacing > > >>or > > >> bpd = image-height + top_and_bottom_borders + > > >> top_and_bottom_padding + line-spacing > > >>? > > >> > > >>Manuel > > >><snip/> > > > > > > Jeremias Maerki > > Jeremias Maerki
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!--
Copyright 2005 The Apache Software Foundation
Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
You may obtain a copy of the License at
http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
limitations under the License.
-->
<!-- $Id: block_border_padding.xml 265720 2005-09-01 13:29:28Z jeremias $ -->
<testcase>
<info>
<p>
This test checks nested blocks with border and padding properties.
</p>
</info>
<fo>
<fo:root xmlns:fo="http://www.w3.org/1999/XSL/Format"; xmlns:svg="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg";>
<fo:layout-master-set>
<fo:simple-page-master master-name="normal" page-width="5in" page-height="5in">
<fo:region-body/>
</fo:simple-page-master>
</fo:layout-master-set>
<fo:page-sequence master-reference="normal" white-space-collapse="true">
<fo:flow flow-name="xsl-region-body" font-size="10pt">
<fo:block background-color="yellow" margin="0pt">
Start of file
</fo:block>
<fo:block background-color="silver" margin="0pt">
Normal text <fo:inline border="solid 5pt red" padding="5pt" background-color="white">inline with border="solid 5pt red" padding="5pt"</fo:inline> normal finish
</fo:block>
<fo:block background-color="yellow" margin="0pt">
End of file
</fo:block>
</fo:flow>
</fo:page-sequence>
</fo:root>
</fo>
<checks>
<!-- First block, no gap -->
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="350000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="360000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="34400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/@bpda"/>
<!-- Nested block of first block -->
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="340000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="350000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="14400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[1]/block[1]/@bpda"/>
<!-- Second block, 5pt gap -->
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@padding-start"/>
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@padding-end"/>
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@padding-before"/>
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@padding-after"/>
<eval expected="10000 10000 10000 10000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="340000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="360000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="44400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/@bpda"/>
<!-- Nested block of second block -->
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="330000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="340000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="14400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[2]/block[1]/@bpda"/>
<!-- third block, no gap between borders but margin around outer block -->
<!-- space before block -->
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[3]/@bpd"/>
<!-- actual block -->
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@space-start"/>
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@space-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="340000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="350000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="34400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/@bpda"/>
<!-- space after block -->
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[5]/@bpd"/>
<!-- Nested block of third block -->
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="330000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="340000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="14400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[4]/block[1]/@bpda"/>
<!-- Fourth block, looks like the second block, but using margin on inner block instead of padding on outer block -->
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#0000ff,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="350000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="360000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="34400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="44400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/@bpda"/>
<!-- Nested block of second block -->
<!-- space before block -->
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[1]/@bpd"/>
<!-- actual block -->
<eval expected="10000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@space-start"/>
<eval expected="10000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@space-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@border-start"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@border-end"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@border-before"/>
<eval expected="(solid,#ff0000,5000)" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@border-after"/>
<eval expected="5000 5000 5000 5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@bap"/>
<eval expected="330000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@ipd"/>
<eval expected="340000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@ipda"/>
<eval expected="14400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@bpd"/>
<eval expected="24400" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[2]/@bpda"/>
<!-- space after block -->
<eval expected="5000" xpath="/areaTree/pageSequence/pageViewport/page[1]/regionViewport/regionBody/mainReference/span/flow/block[6]/block[3]/@bpd"/>
</checks>
</testcase>
inline_border_padding.xml.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
