Hi Fred and all,

On Mar 1, 2017, at 1:00 PM, FRED CAMPER wrote:
> Since I've been known as a rather arch defender of film on film, I have 
> to weigh in a bit on David's side here.


Since I've been known as a regular defender of Fred's occasionally curmudgeonly 
opinions, I have to take issue with his latest post.
David Tetzlaff made a cogent case for DVD projection in an institutional 
context after he had tried several 16mm solutions that proved unsatisfactory. 
His sensible conclusion: "So rather than tear your hair out trying to make it 
‘excellent’, my been-there/done-that advice is just do the best you can with 
the resources you have..."
Fred, however, cited a case in which the only problem was the projectionists' 
inability to thread the film around the sound drum properly. Surely in this 
case "doing the best with the resources you have" means  better training for 
the projectionists, both technically (threading the damn thing) and critically 
(questioning the quality of the sound/image they're projecting).
Sure, 16mm is an expensive hassle; sure, 16mm projection is often hit-or-miss; 
sure, digital video is the often the wiser (or only) option. But hey, don't 
surrender so easily!
 
Deke "diehard" Dusinberre
Paris 

[email protected]
Tel: (33-1) 42.54.38.05

_______________________________________________
FrameWorks mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks

Reply via email to