Follow-up Comment #1, patch #4926 (project freeciv): > Patch #4889 removed the calculation of the cost of an attack, > instead using a flat value of SINGLE_MOVE.
It was already the case before since bug #20361 (except for pf_fuel_map, probably because this algorithm is based on the assumption all costs are equal to SINGLE_MOVE). Your patch seems improve that. > Unfortunately, this isn't sufficient to allow the AI to be > able to use Fighters effectively (or, in fact, any > non-UCF_MISSILE fuel=1 unit), because if any action is > performed on any tile, that tile is set to TB_IGNORE, so > pathfinding shows that the unit would go to the tile, attack, > and then stop, not being able to return to base. Where do you see that the tile is set to TB_IGNORE? I see TB_DONT_LEAVE, which is the right value currently, because as you said below, we cannot be sure where the unit stands after a such action. I am against allowing path-finding to make intermediate actions for the following reasons: * we cannot know where a unit will be after an attack, neither it is still alive ; * we cannot know what will be the move rate after attack (it mays depend of the damages of the unit, and its veteran level, etc.), and handling different move rate on the same pf_map is today far to be possible ; * building path to attack and return to base would make the algorithm very more complicate and slower than what it is currently. About AI fighters: the purpose of pf_fuel_map is to allow to go to tiles the server will make the unit automatically to refuel bases at the end of the turn (else, pf_danger_map would be sufficient). If we want the AI fighters to return after attack, I think the AI code should redeploying a new pf_map after attack. About unit escort: I think the same as for fighters. After attack, the code should check if the unit still has move points and redeploying a pf_map (it would pretty fast if you use map iteration). _______________________________________________________ Reply to this item at: <http://gna.org/patch/?4926> _______________________________________________ Message posté via/par Gna! http://gna.org/ _______________________________________________ Freeciv-dev mailing list Freecivemail@example.com https://mail.gna.org/listinfo/freeciv-dev