Sorry Keith, I don't think we're talking about the same kind of thing. You
are talking about communities in transition, that need to make adjustments to
change and make them in a variety of ways, some healthy, others not. I'm talking
about communities that have been left behind in the process of change,
communities where a lot of things have happened but nothing further really does
- stuck communities where people are losers, but that's OK because it's not your
fault. Someone else has done that to you - government I guess, or whatever. I
describe my impressions of some communities in northern Saskatchewan on my
website at : http://members.eisa.com/~ec086636/north_saskatchewan.htm .
Do take a look. I haven't looked at it for a couple of years but, to my
surprise on revisiting it, I still think it says something.
Ed
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Sunday, January 04, 2004 10:10
AM
Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for
Manhattan (shortened)
Ed,
I venture to chip in here:
At
08:40 04/01/2004 -0500, you wrote:
Thanks
for clarifying, Natalia. I don't think I can add much to what's
already been said except that all people share a common humanity that
consists of a variety of elements, good and bad. How these emerge and
are excercised depends greatly on their circumstances, and only the people
who live with those circumstances have a real understanding of them.
One would expect that the more isolated our Aboriginal communities are, the
less they are influenced by mainstream culture, the healthier they should
be. As one learns from the boreal and Artic communities of Canada, it
ain't necessarily so. In many of the communities, the young sniff gas
or commit suicide, while parents won't stop drinking until they are
dead. Is this the impact of mainstream society, or is it something
else, perhaps endemic to the culture? I would suggest
that there's nothing endemic here. Basically, the individuals in these
indigenous communities (that is, those that are fast becoming ex-communities)
are intrinsically as psychologically healthy as anybody else. But I'm
increasingly convinced that culture shock is vastly under-rated. All this
alcoholism and so forth seems to be repeated everywhere in the world when
cultural adjustments are needed or expected or enforced. Adjusting to a
totally new culture is a multi-generational, historical matter and achieved
only with difficulty. This is the big problem with the Middle East countries,
too -- except it's not alcoholism in their case but aggression against the
west. (They'd like to incorporate some of the products of the west, but only
selectively, and don't realise [understandably] that our products are embedded
within a totally different culture.) In truth, modern civilisation is
disembowelling their communities without offering anything that's obvious or
satisfying in return -- only artificial substitutes (consumer goods).
As a study I did on community and social health in northern Saskatchewan
some ten years ago revealed, we simply don't know. It goes on,
seemingly beyond our ability to understand it. M'mm
..... I think it *is* understandable, as I've tried to indicate above. I think
there *is* a new sense of community building up in the developed countries but
it is a subtle one among the middle-class and intellgentsia, and not based on
locality but on the telephone. It is called "networking" these days. (A brand
new urban-type community to replace the previous countryside communities was
building up fast in the 1860-1930 period in England -- the co-operative
movement, the building societies, the trade unions (the flavour of which I
managed to experience myself in teenagerhood in some of the "slum" districts
of Coventry) -- but this, in turn, has been quickly overwhelmed with the
onward march of technology. There are *no* "ordinary" communities (that is, of
mixed abilities) anywhere in England now. (The only one possible communities I
can think of these days are the football and rugger crowds that meet once a
week at a match. Even the pubs are losing their community basis as they become
restaurants for the middle class.) I think that the need for local community
is very powerful and it will return, but *how* it will do so intrigues and
worries me, and whether it will take place only among the
middle-class/intelligentsia (because only they will have dependable jobs and
homes they can maintain adequately in the coming years) worries me even more.
Keith Hudson
Regards, Ed
----- Original Message -----
- From: Darryl and
Natalia
- To: Ed Weick ; Ray Evans Harrell ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Saturday, January 03, 2004 10:39 PM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
(shortened)
- Hi Ed, More below in italics.
- ----- Original Message -----
- From: Ed Weick
- To: Darryl and
Natalia ; Ray Evans Harrell ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Saturday, January 03, 2004 11:22 AM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
- Natalia, a few comments below.
- Ed
- ----- Original Message -----
- From: Darryl and
Natalia
- To: Ed Weick ; Ray Evans Harrell ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Friday, January 02, 2004 5:52 PM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
- Thank You Ed and Ray,
- Ed, I appreciate what you have written and understand that you have
more in-depth knowledge of Native Peoples' histories than most. Your posts
are indeed sensitively presented, as Ray said.
- Let me mention a couple of things. You said we paint Native people as
simple, peaceful and trusting. I would not use the word simple unless it
were to denote truthful, and by that I give credit to living according to
needs of a full rich life that harms no one and ensures well being within
both community and environment. Simplicity is the prerequisite for all
invention and usually the answer to our most complicated problems,
materially, intellectually and spiritually. Our complication of the
hierarchy of needs has so fractured Western society that we can't even
admit that we need to clean up pollution in our air and water. We fear
more what we'll do without our pollution and wars than the price we pay to
have them. Short term gain disinherits the children, and reverses almost
every bit of progress we have made, but our priority of needs continues to
cloud our minds to the fact that we are seriously dishonouring our home
planet, and the life upon it including ourselves. Even our intellectual
solutions, I'd suggest, are competing for complexity, and come with a
hefty price. Most often as well, these solutions are giving into the
reality of complication as a necessary thing, thereby overlooking the
obvious as the solution.
- Unfortunately, today's Native people, because of modern society,
cannot afford not to deal with the complexities that have been thrust
upon them. I think, however, that their belief in what is obviously a
healthy and well spirited approach to life will win out in the long run,
as it will for all of us.
- I don't know about this. Native
people, even before contact with whites, led lives every bit as complex as
Europeans or indeed any other people. They had to battle with
hunger, cold and disease and very often with each other. They had to
govern themselves and placate whatever Gods or spirits they had to deal
with. To raise them up on some kind of pedestal is, IMHO, to deny
them their basic humanity.
- *** Before contact with whites, Native people did not deal with
forty-fifty different government departments just to live in accordance
with law. Displacement, suppression of spirituality/religion, families
torn apart, forced sterilization, abuses and injustices of all sorts,
having to abandon a way of life and adopt new survival methods within the
asphyxiating pressures of racism. These were additional complications
which I do not suggest they can't deal with. I believe you are
misinterpreting what I am saying about the rewards of a life without
Western complications. Their life was as complicated as a life need be.
This is not to say that their lives were not complex. It is that their
focus was more aligned with good values, in my opinion. This is not
deification. There are other people round the globe who (have) lived as
peacefully or even more so. But this is their land, and in my estimate,
their basic beliefs, had they been followed by the colonizers, would have
resulted in a healthier environment with fewer injustices. I do not
believe in deification of my fellow humans. We are equal in every sense
that is true, and when we forget that it is true, we are crying out for
help.
- I am aware that not all Native people lived peacefully, nor do they
today. I made a generalization, which was not intended to deify, but drawn
as a comparative. Their way of life was generally more respectful of
others and the life around them, otherwise towards the end of Native
peoples' fifty to one hundred thousand years of responsible dominion of
the lands the colonizers would have found a toxic wasteland. This has
nothing to do with lack of ingenuity, sophistication or even luck. It was
the result of living a life more in keeping with the laws of Creation. I
call the colonizers mean and ignorant because they were both. They did
intend genocide, and they were ignorant, just as most people (governments)
are today, because they would destroy or exploit whatever came their way,
making their own needs, so-devised, as pre-eminent.
- I'm not sure of what you mean by "the laws of Creation". If there are such
things, are you suggesting that some people have special access to them
and others do not? And, as far as Native tenure over the lands of
the Americas goes, anything I've read suggests that it does not extend
back more than 20k years and 30k years at the very most. For a very
readable book on the topic, take a look at Elaine Dewar, "Bones -
Discovering the First Americans". And, as for the colonizers, they
were indeed mean though not, as I argued previously, necessarily
ignorant. And, for the most part, they may not even have that
mean. Ever so many people came to Canada to escape the tyranny,
poverty and oppressions of Europe and to take up land that they genuinely
believed were empty and therefore available for farming. My
grandfather, a God fearing man without a mean bone in his body, was one of
them. My point is that people in high places may have known those
lands were not empty, but I don't think the ordinary pioneer farmer gave
it much thought. He just wanted to look after the survival of his
family.
- As above, I do not belief specialness leads to anything but our
undoing. Yes, I heard about the thirty year tenure, and thought I'd
hypothesize a bit for the sake of accuracy when posterity reads this.
Keith's posts got me wondering, but I think there's still a lot to uncover
about human history all over the globe. We disagree about "ignorant", yet
I would say it of the Canadian government isolating the Japanese
immigrants in special camps, of not just German government,for
enslavement/genocide of the Slavic, Jewish, Gypsy, etc. people during
WWII, and of the U.S. government for today's overseas oil wars. The
ordinary citizen of any of these countries is not necessarily responsible
for poor government, but colonizers knew pretty quickly that they were
deposing Native people of their lands. They didn't usually try to be fair
about forced sharing/turfing. Native people were more willing to share,
given their belief that no one owns what "Creator" has provided as a gift.
Also, the notion that colonizers came to escape tyranny was usually
negated by burning uppity women as witches, intolerance of Native peoples'
religion, and slavery of blacks--to mention but a few.
- "Laws of Creation" as in the Creator's Laws--nothing to do with
Creationist theory. I thought that consistent with Christian
understanding, but perhaps I could say God's Laws -- also up for
interpretation by humans.
- Trust was used by me in every sense that Christian philosophy would
imply. The alleged message of Jesus was to always trust in your
brother/sister. Where would we be, for example, without genuine
forgiveness? This is not the same as saying trust blindly or simply to
obey the laws of religion. If one chooses to trust another knowing that
great harm will come then you honour neither party. Trust that deep down
everyone wants peace, trust that we all come from the same Source, and
that we would do harm to our own selves, or dishonour the Creator's trust,
when we harm others--that is the trust of which I speak.
- I think Native people learned not to trust
us very early on, whether by "trust" you mean something legal or something
more fundamental. Quite rightly, they never did trust us and still
don't, which is why all those treaties, agreements, pieces of legislation
and government departments dealing with White/Native relationships.
A few years ago, Angela Slaughter, a Micmac, and I put together a primer
on the treaties and claims process in Canada and you might take a look at
it at:
- http://members.eisa.com/~ec086636/native_claims.htm
- I meant it in the fundamental sense, and I didn't think that my
Christian example could be otherwise interpreted. Yes, they did trust
white man in the beginning. Today, that trust is still extended to
individuals, though rightly not to government.
- I'll check out the above site, and thanks for the road trip
account.
- Natalia
- Regards, Ed
- ----- Original Message -----
- From: Ed Weick
- To: Ray Evans Harrell ; Darryl and Natalia ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Friday, January 02, 2004 9:53 AM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
- Thanks, Ray. I'll file your posting
for future reference. Incidentally, I visited the site of the
Wounded Knee massacre in 1983. If you want my impressions, go to http://members.eisa.com/~ec086636/black_hills.htm
.
- Ed
_______________________________________________ Futurework
mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://fes.uwaterloo.ca/mailman/listinfo/futurework
Keith
Hudson, Bath, England, <www.evolutionary-economics.org>
|