2015-07-16 18:49 GMT+02:00 Roman Shaposhnik <ro...@shaposhnik.org>: > On Thu, Jul 16, 2015 at 1:47 AM, Emmanuel Lécharny <elecha...@gmail.com> > wrote: >> Le 16/07/15 10:41, Justin Mclean a écrit : >>> Hi, >>> >>>> This vote passes with 4 binding "+1" votes, no "0" notes, and 2 "-1" >>>> binding votes. >>> If you read carefully I think you find there were 3 -1 votes on the binary >>> releases. >> >> True. I -1 the binary release. Interesting case : should we release if >> we have as many -1 than +1 ? > > Personally, I'm disappointed in the podling for not taking > care of feedback that seems really easy to take care of. >
Again, saying we don't take this seriously is at best an error and honestly unfair. We take it very seriously and I am very disappointed that you think we don't. If you look at the commits, you will see that we started fixing those issues *before* the release vote was finished. We *deserved* a release for the community and *it was critical*. The reasons why were explained on private@, and we could *not* afford another 2x72 voting period + 24h mitigation period, that could also potentially fail the IPMC vote (yes, because despite the fact that we fixed all issues reported for our first trial, the second had undetected errors too). Also, why having rules for votes if you don't follow them? Like it or not, it passed the vote. Not releasing would not have been serious, and we could have missed the short timeframe we have given the vacations of the team. It's also unfair because we took *very seriously* the comments for the first attempt of the release, a few weeks ago, and fixed *all of them* (and did even more than what you asked us to do). So I think our community deserved that release more than having the perfect L&N files (especially because as we said, the License file contains more, but not less, than required), and as Paul said, all jars produces *do* have them. > That's my strong expectation as well. If we're doing this whole > mentoring thing -- lets do it right. I sincerely hope my position is understood this time. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
