On May 12, 2011, at 5:31 PM, Uwe Schindler wrote: > Who logs the stuff there? In my opinion, a meeting on Lucene-Rev is also > "private" - or is this different somehow? What's difference between a > private talk between two or three people in a bar at Lucene Revolution > without somebody writing down a log? A log can also be written if somebody > else talks with me in a private Skype chat!
+1. If it didn't happen on the mailing list, it didn't happen. To me, that does not mean we must not discuss Lucene/Solr together off list here and there. This is just one of those lines I think most people understand to a degree. Perhaps we should do a little self check and reign in a little - but let's be honest - two developers getting together and speeding through some stuff is no different than one dev thinking through a lot on his own. You then bring it to the mailing list since otherwise it didn't happen. Other than that, we are all big boys and I think we can self regulate. It starts getting into fuzzy territory of sub groups regularly meeting or something - but like I said - I think everyone largely gets it. Personally I've found enough to make it to JIRA issues to be satisfied. If I thought something was missing, I'd ask for more detail about the issue. I don't see others doing that much, but perhaps I've missed it. You want to curate JIRA issues well in either case. - Mark Miller lucidimagination.com Lucene/Solr User Conference May 25-26, San Francisco www.lucenerevolution.org
