-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 On 11-06-2011 20:48, Mike Frysinger wrote: > On Saturday, June 11, 2011 16:24:00 Ciaran McCreesh wrote: >> On Sat, 11 Jun 2011 15:58:43 -0400 Mike Frysinger wrote: >>>> So, effectively the QA team lead can appoint the people who elect >>>> him. I'm not at all implying that Diego would abuse his position, >>>> but still I think that this is not a sane situation. >>> >>> it does seem trivial to remove people who disagree with you and thus >>> cement an echo chamber >> >> Are you talking in a hypothetical future situation, or has this already >> happened? If so, can you point to an example of where Diego's been >> removing people for disagreeing with him, rather than for disagreeing >> with the Council? > > how is disagreeing with a Council decision valid grounds either ? punting > people because they disagree with any group isn't really valid. > -mike
It was not about disagreeing with Council but actively going against an approved policy when the team is responsible for enforcing policies in the tree. This is why in my proposal for the review of GLEP 48 I added a point stating that acting against established policies would constitute ground to be removed from the team. The point about the QA lead having to approve anyone wanting to join the team should be evaluated with the background that the council will surely pay attention to who the QA lead accepts or refuses in the team and that if he acts in an inappropriate manner he may be subject to a devrel bug. - -- Regards, Jorge Vicetto (jmbsvicetto) - jmbsvicetto at gentoo dot org Gentoo- forums / Userrel / Devrel / KDE / Elections / RelEng -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/ iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJN9piSAAoJEC8ZTXQF1qEPI8MP/3reALc0xY6JXhOQ1mIDiDjh tugb3K7DYxWn4o3g78CBc1EDjZG+WTnoNTvhBC3KnFvdR2jCyuTyoxTgrdiyMCBt Z92klv9fWYwn5IgjRXD3PthG//uen+fpWS5BAvL9PjjeqiR5WOGlfavqbutsAvmy 7zCerkrNgBIzUyvgDBTRMcnftNMwbXu/fOtkVp9m203KjZuvzge606OKBcjiKYbG uZ+Vw2pMfvJ0MycoRdI3a411/RuouISpRlWKoQR6QpFtgago9qf4Gx4MqY1qXaV9 2iY/fBAau1AmVy3IAqFDG1IvBM1QDr9C3wuGqX2nlLQF8V+3BazIputV3sqYhxwd scxJSzJlH+SMnO5+IkyR2Y7WaW9byIQb/pV/weIxfGqEoXmx7kfVSyal55rwLTYF Yd7n0Y8RtHZswYCIxYpZ/kTAlJDl+lpMIJ3lsu9CIIrrc6SgWrQZL4XVEM/CkdVl Oi5VH/6XQrYaVYF53lHPow7LWeRMf/eT/1ZRy164Gsp3x/G1t4GfKYS8egiMSqAy 6TF0Le/tJqBreanwvihVJRas3D27I74//0asIQeu9jgxRnAvaWOvMx5uCFTMfr5k E1rt5Bl7i5qRLs//hA9MPEGa9Tywx5muf9SQ3BH2D8jNlHcOWdDUntylcU1ZTeOA D9Ahs1NzxyQbOzxvTQG9 =QNSu -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
