-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 17/06/2011 03:30 πμ, Mike Frysinger wrote: > On Monday, June 13, 2011 19:09:06 Jorge Manuel B. S. Vicetto wrote: >> On 11-06-2011 20:48, Mike Frysinger wrote: >>> On Saturday, June 11, 2011 16:24:00 Ciaran McCreesh wrote: >>>> On Sat, 11 Jun 2011 15:58:43 -0400 Mike Frysinger wrote: >>>>>> So, effectively the QA team lead can appoint the people who elect >>>>>> him. I'm not at all implying that Diego would abuse his position, >>>>>> but still I think that this is not a sane situation. >>>>> >>>>> it does seem trivial to remove people who disagree with you and thus >>>>> cement an echo chamber >>>> >>>> Are you talking in a hypothetical future situation, or has this already >>>> happened? If so, can you point to an example of where Diego's been >>>> removing people for disagreeing with him, rather than for disagreeing >>>> with the Council? >>> >>> how is disagreeing with a Council decision valid grounds either ? >>> punting people because they disagree with any group isn't really valid. >> >> It was not about disagreeing with Council but actively going against an >> approved policy when the team is responsible for enforcing policies in >> the tree. >> >> This is why in my proposal for the review of GLEP 48 I added a point >> stating that acting against established policies would constitute ground >> to be removed from the team. > > that isnt what Ciaran said, and what you describe no one has shown me doing. > thus the only logical conclusions that one can draw from this: > - Diego mistakenly removed me without knowing all the facts > or > - i was removed for purely voicing disagreement > -mike
This is exactly what I've trying to explain in many many e-mails. You and Samuli agreed to follow the policy. Not removing old packages does *NOT* violate the policy. I am not sure why this is so hard for someone to understand the difference. This is reason why I left as well. Because you were removed with no proof of policy violation. - -- Regards, Markos Chandras / Gentoo Linux Developer / Key ID: B4AFF2C2 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (GNU/Linux) iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJN+xbjAAoJEPqDWhW0r/LCDBcQAJNSH6E4eiB4GFt7nSWkT1Ou u9XbcaANAOBHNgt0Ydg/QJF2w0ON8vo/hk8y2gvxOOKXlukT21teDAQ4A7BTiRHa zz7m51TXyTXAjBUavam6x9KKgdTTnlHkRpVMCxh6HHG1K8n7qHFrswMxr41V8cD6 oZ4sP0UZPXKA7qslDv44MGF7gPQyUcCCKAYVOBOCWtNOr9LABxfSQnX/s6ZtSEHy uvQ8FD4cL/BYN83NnoB+fUUqzFwiyz1xlZDD3QrvhlsYNi3QSM+Zp6t2X08eWci5 ScSLUqB5kAZVZH9SzxNjpGeZu95A5hr0w6goCd6dxUqdUne/2k99HwPp876PRiq1 jvcRMEHvvKQdVN8Tdqs8fiSxVZBcBlG4N9ief6FyAKrNgcJ8aaLAPb9CeuqWcGnE mmWrtql5QJR3n5AENNOWUzG41RfBRf6QqoF9WYLDuIEwXOfcE2mpWmtL473fXtUK 8PsLSZ9ZXYVDhGxAAai1ZFCgTjbzCv635V0nXpZm2w6PBsDpuKRXtjUJCRbhoXVP lFBrDLDOyI/qFf7PfYQfi3nwUucmZIJTm3g+hSt1nuE9nvx2qjdx9FzN79DqattC RfiZQJFxXc9baa1qz0yt1TZHmmbFmUuX/moIxSSk0XbzYhEl5uJUuJeh/b8MGjeT 18nIZ+fNSEaHwyc/IHSk =0nlz -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
