-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Dude, you don't know what you're talking about, really. To delete a 
file = to mark a file "deleted". There are 2 cases:

1. just mark the file as deleted and then use the space whenever 
needed: 
- - pros: speed (you just have to write a few bytes to mark a file for 
deletion, on fat systems just 1 byte afaik), undeleting stuff (if you 
are telling me that you never needed an undelete program.. well..)

- - cons: some other unwanted people might undelete stuff you don't want 
to have undeleted... 

2. delete entire file (like overwriting the space occupied by the 
deleted data it with other garbage data)
- - pros: fewer chance of undeletion (NOT null-chances, since with 
proper (expensive) equipment, somebody might still recover the data.. 
incredible isn't it ? that's why many programs let you choose how 
many times to overwrite the deleted portion ... (even hundreds of 
times)

- - cons: SPEED !!! if the system would have to overwrite every file you 
delete, the writing speed would be half on deletion !!  (example: to 
delete 1 700MB movie on my system would take 0.01 sec at most for 
case 1 and about 20-30 secs for case2)

Linux and Windows and any system which cares about itself and its 
users should use the first variant by default, letting the users 
choose if they want that kind of security like file shredded by other 
programs.. At least on ext2 it is possible to undelete stuff, and 
maybe on the others too, but nobody really cared to design such 
programs...

by the way, deleting a file will not put it in linux (by default at 
least) in "a hidden dir". The space which is marked as deleted can be 
used by the system at any time, and it appears as "free space" (not 
like windows recycle bin). 

If I didn't understand you correctly, please excuse me. 

On Wednesday 26 November 2003 04:33, Hemmann, Volker Armin wrote:
> On Tuesday 25 November 2003 19:31, Oliver Lange wrote:
> > Redeeman wrote:
> > > its not a minus, its also a feature, sometimes if i delete data
> > > i really want it to disappear!
> >
> > Well if i want to delete a file forever, there are many tools out
> > there which do the job. For example, Krusader offers a "shred"
> > command, other tools work from the console. These tools overwrite
> > the whole file with Null-Bytes before deleting them.
>
> that is the same like buying a car.. and buying a second one for
> left turns...
>
> If I delete a file, I want it to be gone. Nothing else.
>
> rm means remove not 'park this in a hidden dir' or 'obfuscate the
> name'.
>
> That windows does not realy 'delete' but merely renames and
> overwrites files, is only an additional sign for windos weak
> design. Undeleting there is not a feature, but a way to exploit the
> shortenings of fat.
>
> > --
> > [EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list

- -- 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.3 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQE/xBX9HMw8JJ+r9ucRAhhMAKClTGGz4sv4OpHKKqRWuO50pJIoFwCgncPs
omhi4sFBmxpe74QaFWrxTp8=
=WVnC
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list

Reply via email to