Nathan Carl Summers <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:

> I took a look at the new image dialogs on the list today, and I made
> a few improvements.  I've posted them at
> http://wilber.gimp.org/~rock/NewDialogSimple.png and
> http://wilber.gimp.org/~rock/NewDialogExpanded.png

Sorry, but I fail to see any improvements in these mockups. The icon
next to the memory size as well as the bold label "Memory Required"
don't add any value, waste screen estate and distract from the
important parts of the dialog. Centering the unit menu next to the
size entries does IMO look horrible since it deviates from the table
layout of the dialog. Using a frame for the template selection seems
wrong because a frame's supposed to group elements. The template menu
is a single element and in your mockup it stands completely

I think Jimmac and Tigert did a very good jo with their mockup and I
don't see much room for improvement. IMHO we should stick to it.

Gimp-developer mailing list

Reply via email to