Hi Emily,

On Thu, 15 Aug 2019, Emily Shaffer wrote:

> On Thu, Aug 15, 2019 at 10:07:57PM +0200, Johannes Schindelin wrote:
> >
> > On Thu, 15 Aug 2019, Derrick Stolee wrote:
> >
> > > On 8/14/2019 10:34 PM, Emily Shaffer wrote:
> > > > diff --git a/git-bugreport.sh b/git-bugreport.sh
> > > > new file mode 100755
> > > > index 0000000000..2200703a51
> > > > --- /dev/null
> > > > +++ b/git-bugreport.sh
> > >
> > > At first I was alarmed by "What? another shell script?" but this
> > > command should prioritize flexibility and extensibility over speed.
> > > Running multiple processes shouldn't be too taxing for what we are
> > > trying to do here.
> >
> > Git for Windows sometimes receives bug reports about Bash not being able
> > to start (usually it is a DLL base address problem, related to the way
> > Cygwin and MSYS2 emulate `fork()`).
> Hmm. In a case like this, then, how is someone using GfW at all?

On Windows, there are native command-line interpreters available that
are _not_ Bash: PowerShell and CMD.

These days, you can get away with using Git _without_ a working Unix
shell most of the time. There are only preciously few commands left that
are still written as scripts, and most of these seem to be used less
often than one might think:

        - submodule
        - bisect
        - filter-branch
        - instaweb
        - mergetool
        - some uncommon merge strategies
        - rebase -p (already deprecated)
        - several CVS/Subversion/Arch/Quilt integrations
        - send-email (only relevant for mailing list centric projects,
          again, not very common any longer)
        - request-pull (I would not be surprised if this is specific for
          the Linux project, as if that project was even close to the
          main user of Git)

So as long as you don't use submodules, and as long as you are unaware
of the `bisect` command, which would comprise the majority of Git users
in my experience, you can totally use Git for Windows without using Bash
or Perl, i.e. without using the Cygwin/MSYS2 runtime that seems to be
one of the common causes for trouble in Git for Windows.

> Embarrassingly, I don't actually have a way to try it out for myself.
> It seems there's no GUI, and users are using it through the command line
> in mingw, so when you say "bash doesn't start" do you mean "users can't
> use the mingw prompt at all"?

There is no MinGW prompt.

MinGW stands for "Minimal GNU on Windows", but it really refers to a way
to compile native Win32 programs via GCC. Meaning that some of the POSIX
functionality Unix/Linux developers have come to expect is unavailable.
For example, `fork()`. Which means that there is no native port of Bash
to Windows, at least not that _I_ am aware of.

Git for Windows comes with a "Git Bash", which is essentially a Bash
built against the MSYS2 runtime (i.e. it is much more like a Cygwin
executable than like a Win32 executable).

The common way to run Git for Windows is actually via `git.exe`,
independent of what particular command-line interpreter you prefer.

> > In such a case, `git bugreport` would only be able to offer a reason for
> > yet another bug report instead of adding useful metadata.
> >
> > Something to keep in mind when deciding how to implement this command.
> Yeah, that's an interesting point, thanks for bringing it up. So, in the
> case when bash won't start at all, what does that failure look like? How
> much of Git can users still use? For example, would they be able to get
> far enough to run a binary git-bugreport?

See above.

If I were you, I would not write `git bugreport` as anything but a
built-in, written in C. Unless there are _really_ good reasons not to
[*1*].  And quite honestly, I don't see any such reasons.


Footnote *1*: One good reason to use the MSYS2 Bash would be to be able
to use MSYS2's POSIX emulation layer, e.g. to talk to the SSH agent
(that is also an MSYS2 program, meaning that it communicates via
emulated Unix sockets, which is a facility not available to native Win32

Another valid reason to use the MSYS2 Bash is to be able to talk to the
(emulated) pseudo TTYs provided by the MSYS2 runtime, e.g. when running
inside a MinTTY window, which is the default for Git Bash in Git for

Reply via email to