On 13 August 2013 21:46, Jeff King <p...@peff.net> wrote:
> Like I said, I do not have a particular use for it, but I don't think it
> would hurt anybody who does not use it. If you want to polish it up into
> a real patch with docs and tests, I don't mind.
I'll have a go at this.
> The only downside I can think of is that we might want to use the
> subsection in "include.SUBSECTION.*" for some other limiting conditions
> (e.g., "only include this config when running version >= X.Y", or even
> "include only when environment variable FOO is true").
It seems as though gitconfig doesn't have a standard way of dealing
with 'sub-subsections', which is essentially what this is trying to
It makes sense that there could be different 'modes' of includes.
These could be the ones you mentioned already, such as repo and env,
but could also be things like branch where the config changes
depending on which branch you are on. Ideally, multiple entries per
mode would be allowed.
Implementing all that initially would be overkill however if this sort
of functionality is desirable the ability to easily add new modes
would be a great boon down the track.
The four pieces of information we need to include are that this is an
include, the path to the include, the mode, and the mode specific
parameter. Your proposal is to allow the sub-subsection by
concatenating with a ":" like this
path = <path>
Alternatively, we could allow chaining of subsections (couldn't find
any previous discussion on this) by adding whitespace between each
subsection. Seems like lots of potentially unnecessary work, but maybe
this has already been discussed or is the most appropriate way of
$ git config --global include.repo./magic/.path ~/.gitconfig-magic
[include repo "/magic/"]
path = .gitconfig-magic
We could also require a unique key that grouped the options together.
This seems like the easiest and most flexible method, and doesn't
require any 'special' considerations for the subsection. It would be
harder for a user to configure, and the concept of a mode seems less
$ git config --global include.magicrepos.mode repo
$ git config --global include.magicrepos.param /magic/
$ git config --global include.magicrepos.path ~/.gitconfig-magic
mode = repo
param = "/magic/"
path = ~/.gitconfig-magic
Of the three I probably think the subsection chaining is the nicest
overall, though your original "repo:" proposal seems to be the easiest
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in
the body of a message to majord...@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html