> > Hey, now there's a thought!  How about a facility for typesetting
classical
> > analysis (such as: C#m: Im V[6 4] Im with the 6 stacked on top of the
> > four--look at Walter Piston's *Harmony* for copious examples)?  >-)
>
> Aha!  I've got a book that tries to teach jazz this way...it's a
> disaster.

Not suprised...  ;-)

> But I guess this is where the inversion stuff really comes
> into its own.  Can this chord-naming method handle complicated
> harmonies, or just more simple major/minor harmonies?

As far as I know, it can handle seventh chords, but much further than that
the notation gets messy (think four numbers next to your roman numeral for
9th chords ;-).  I think the most jazz-like stuff that Piston examined was
by Wagner (he doesn't even attempt to use it seriously for Schoenberg and
the like)...

-- Shamus


Reply via email to