Stevan -
As always succinct points.  Comments inline.
Best
Keith

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Keith G Jeffery      Director International Relations       STFC
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The contents of this email are sent in confidence for the use of the intended 
recipient only.  If you are not one of the intended recipients do not take 
action on it or show it to anyone else, but return this email to the sender and 
delete your copy of it
The STFC telecommunications systems may be monitored in accordance with the 
policy available from 
<http://dlitd.dl.ac.uk/policy/monitoring/monitoring%20statement.htm>.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of 
Stevan Harnad
Sent: 07 May 2012 14:55
To: Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci)
Cc: [email protected]
Subject: [GOAL] Some discussion points for the UK OA initiative

The UK's continuing leadership and initiative in opening access to research is 
wonderful and only to be applauded, supported and encouraged.
[Keith Jeffery] thanks for recognising that there are many 'warriors' in UK 
working away at it.

To help make the initiative focused and effective, I would suggest that the 
following four questions should be given some thought.

If "UK public access to UK publicly funded research" is to be the guiding 
principle, and the two ways of providing it are either the Green OA 
self-archiving of articles published for free in subscription journals (GRNOA) 
or the publishing of articles in Gold OA journals for a fee (GLDOA):

1. GLOBALISM. Is the objective really just UK public access to UK research? Is 
the purpose of publishing research not to have it taken up, built upon, used 
and applied in further research and applications globally, and reciprocally, to 
the benefit of the public that funded the research? (And aren't UK OA mandates 
likely to inspire complementary, reciprocal OA mandates globally?)

[Keith Jeffery] 
[Keith Jeffery] the objective is global access of course but there is leverage 
in the 'UK public access to UK publicly funded research' argument.  This is 
counteracted by the government tax-take from UK-based publishers and the 
potential damage to learned societies who rely on publishing for part of their 
income.  The problem is reciprocity so like gamblers at a card table it is 'who 
blinks first'.  I believe UK (funders) will go ahead anyway despite the 
reciprocity concerns.  There is a certain kudos (moral high ground) in making 
the research outputs available openly and toll-free.  There are also the 
well-rehearsed advantages for the author of higher citations as well as for the 
community in potentially faster research cycles, higher quality due to wider 
scrutiny etc. As a safety-net, if other countries do not reciprocate, open 
could be closed.

2. RECIPROCITY. Does paying unilaterally for GLDOA for UK research -- making UK 
research freely accessible globally, but with the UK still having to pay 
subscriptions to access non-UK research -- make sense?  Is GRNOA, which  does 
not entail double payment, not more likely to  inspire global reciprocity? And 
would  global GRNOA not lead to GLDOA thereafter anyway?

[Keith Jeffery] 
[Keith Jeffery] (lack of) reciprocity is a fear among some in UK.  I detect 
that we have lost the Green is better than Gold argument in UK, not least 
because the powerful biomedical community stampeded into Gold (but let us see 
what the Finch committee comes up with).  However, they can coexist (as 
recognised by the RCUK funders) and I suspect the publishers will not convert 
wholly to Gold for a very long while and meantime maybe the higher (than 
subscription) costs of Gold for highly productive institutions will reduce 
submissions to Gold channels and encourage green (or more likely a completely 
different publishing model along the lines of liquid publications with 
specialised reviewing mechanisms for which sustainable models are not yet in 
place).  I do not believe Global Green would lead to Global Gold.  The 
motivations and business models behind each are too dissimilar - as are the 
likely end-games.

3. BOOKS. What about books resulting from UK publicly funded research? Would it 
not be a better idea for the time being to merely recommend rather than require 
that books  be made OA, rather than risk resistance from authors who are happy 
to give away their journal articles but not their books?

[Keith Jeffery] 
[Keith Jeffery] I think we need (generalising somewhat) to distinguish 
monographs (with an academic and non-remuneration intention) from textbooks 
(with an educational and remuneration intention).  For me the former are 
candidates for mandated green OA.  Currently monographs are excluded from the 
RCUK position.

4. DATA. What about authors who do not wish to make their research data freely 
accessible to all immediately, having gathered it for the purpose of analyzing 
and data-mining it themselves? Would it not be a better idea for the time being 
to merely recommend rather than require that data be made OA as soon as 
possible, rather than risk resistance from authors who are happy to give away 
their journal articles but not their data?

[Keith Jeffery] 
[Keith Jeffery] you are right to raise this.  Different communities / domains 
of research have different practices with embargo periods on data to allow the 
project leader / team to have publication precedence.  So we have publishers 
wanting embargos for articles and communities wanting embargos for data (and 
probably also associated software which may raise issues concerning 
confidentiality / patenting).  The UK funding councils are pushing for the same 
conditions on data as on publications but the document is not yet finalised. 
One solution would be to make data available openly but to have agreements that 
any researcher working on the data other than the original project team should 
(a) notify of intent to publish (b) ideally co-publish with the original team  
or (c) minimally cite the original team publication and dataset/software.  It 
is all a matter of research ethics.  The present competitive research world 
does not encourage such ethics.  Again the Finch committee output will be 
interesting.  The whole area of research data from publicly-funded research has 
been caught up with the open 'data.gov' (public service information, semantic 
web, linked open data) agenda.  While  the two certainly are related, I am not 
convinced the semantic web / LOD browsing over data to find the nearest 
hospital or local government office - or crime statistics in your neighbourhood 
or league table ratings of local schools -  is the same as managing terabytes 
(or more) of research data with specialised and complex software.

Best
Keith

Stevan Harnad

_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
-- 
Scanned by iCritical.

_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to