Is it not the case that there are two parts to the data issue, and these two parts are often conflated? There is data mining (mining the underlying data associated with scholarly papers), and there is text mining, pulling data out from the text of scholarly papers (i.e. treating papers as data). As I understand it, both these things present somewhat different problems, and so presumably require different solutions.
For instance, I am told that researchers concerned about text mining argue that when their institution buys a subscription to an electronic journal they should be acquiring not only the right to read the papers in it, but the right to text mine them too. Publishers, however, do not see it that way. This is not the same problem as that described by Keith below I think. That said, not all OA publishers are text-mining friendly either. Nature reports that "of the 2.4 million abstracts listed by PubMedCentral, only 400,000 (17%) are licensed for text-mining." (http://www.nature.com/news/trouble-at-the-text-mine-1.10184). I hope the UK government is clear that these are different problems requiring different solutions. >> 4. DATA. What about authors who do not wish to make their research data freely accessible to all immediately, having gathered it for the purpose of analyzing and data-mining it themselves? Would it not be a better idea for the time being to merely recommend rather than require that data be made OA as soon as possible, rather than risk resistance from authors who are happy to give away their journal articles but not their data? [Keith Jeffery] [Keith Jeffery] you are right to raise this. Different communities / domains of research have different practices with embargo periods on data to allow the project leader / team to have publication precedence. So we have publishers wanting embargos for articles and communities wanting embargos for data (and probably also associated software which may raise issues concerning confidentiality / patenting). The UK funding councils are pushing for the same conditions on data as on publications but the document is not yet finalised. One solution would be to make data available openly but to have agreements that any researcher working on the data other than the original project team should (a) notify of intent to publish (b) ideally co-publish with the original team or (c) minimally cite the original team publication and dataset/software. It is all a matter of research ethics. The present competitive research world does not encourage such ethics. Again the Finch committee output will be interesting. The whole area of research data from publicly-funded research has been caught up with the open 'data.gov' (public service information, semantic web, linked open data) agenda. While the two certainly are related, I am not convinced the semantic web / LOD browsing over data to find the nearest hospital or local government office - or crime statistics in your neighbourhood or league table ratings of local schools - is the same as managing terabytes (or more) of research data with specialised and complex software. Best Keith _______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
