[SH]: So all in all, both data OA and Libre OA face problems that Green
Gratis OA does not face.

[PM-R] And they deserve careful, accurate discussion.

>>

I agree. It seems that there is much to be explicated here, particularly as data OA relates to the wider OA movement.

Meanwhile, here is another link for those interested in the topic (if they haven't come across it already):
http://caseybergman.wordpress.com/2012/03/02/why-are-there-so-few-efforts-to-text-mine-the-open-access-subset-of-pubmed-central/

Richard Poynder


Peter Murray-Rust wrote:


On Mon, May 7, 2012 at 11:11 PM, Stevan Harnad <[email protected]> wrote:
Richard, you are quite right that making research data open for all
to mine is not the same thing as making the texts of research articles
(Libre) OA for text-mining, and you are also right that there are
different problems associated with each.

I should point out that Libre OA as defined by Suber-Harnad does not automatically give rights for textmining. Libre OA indicates that "some permission barriers are removed" - it does not indicate what those barriers are. For example by default an toll-access article may not be posted in an Institutional repository. The permission to post it is the removal of a barrier. However that permission does not allow text-mining as the copyirgh and re-use rights remain with other parties (publisher or repository or both). For this reason the phrase "LibreOA" is operationally meaningless - it may have political value. Wiley claims "fully open access" for its Gold hybrid and no doubt would label it as LibreOA but I can see no difference between it and publisher-supported Green OA other than that Wiley is 3000 USD better off and the research community is worse and that the authors can claim they have "Gold OA".

I urge people to realise that textmining requires an explicit statement of rights of re-use.
 
Making article texts open for text-mining calls for Libre OA.

Specifically it calls for BOAI-compliant LibreOA, not just "LibreOA". It also calls for clear licensing with something equivalent to CC-BY or CC0.
 

But few publishers endorse Libre OA, for fear of 3rd-party free-riders.

BMC and PLoS do this enthusastically. I have seen no serious evidence of free-riders.
 
(Moreover, some flavors of Libre OA call for further re-use rights
that even some authors would not wish to grant.)

This statement is made without evidence and is typical of some of the casual and damaging inaccuracies made in this debate. I have no evidence that people fail to publish in PLoS and BMC because of their worry about re-use.
 

So all in all, both data OA and Libre OA face problems that Green
Gratis OA does not face.

And they deserve careful, accurate discussion.

P.

--
Peter Murray-Rust
Reader in Molecular Informatics
Unilever Centre, Dep. Of Chemistry
University of Cambridge
CB2 1EW, UK
+44-1223-763069


_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal


_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to