Sure, career is nothing bad in itself, but if "career survival" is the
primary motivation and the main factor that drives ones' decisions - as
hypothesised in your blog post - then its proper name is "careerism".
Changing the system is a responsibility of everyone: every scholar -
senior or junior - who cares about doing good science. For some reasons
(experience, reputation) senior scholars have more power to make
changes, but on the other hand, junior scholars have more fresh ideas on
what could be done and more skills (entrepreneurial, programming etc.)
to do this.
Definitely, some senior scholars feel fine in the current system and can
be afraid of changes, although I'd be careful with generalizing this
statement to all senior faculty. On this mailing list alone there are
many senior academics who strive for changes and have done a lot to
change the system - without their efforts we would have 1% open access
today rather than 20%.
-Marcin
On 11/07/2012 06:52 PM, Eric F. Van de Velde wrote:
Marcin said:
The statement that "scholars publish for prestige" is an euphemism for
"scholars are careerists who care more about tenure than quality and
meaningfulness of their research". I don't believe this.
I most definitely do not believe that myself for a minute. I don't do
euphemisms. The young and untenured need to publish in prestigious
journals for career survival. I don't see why that needs to be turned
into the negative "careerism". If you want to be a researcher, you
need a compelling cv. Publications are a big part of that.
Changing the system should primarily be a responsibility of senior
faculty and university administrators. Unfortunately, they are
beneficiaries of the current system, give it more value than it
deserves, and are probably too cautious in their attempts to change it.
--Eric.
http://scitechsociety.blogspot.com
Google Voice: (626) 898-5415
Telephone: (626) 376-5415
Skype: efvandevelde -- Twitter: @evdvelde
E-mail: [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
On Tue, Nov 6, 2012 at 1:56 PM, Marcin Wojnarski
<[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>>
wrote:
Eric's distinction between publishing for communication or for
prestige is quite thought-provoking, if not provocative. Does
anyone have an idea how many authors fall to each group? What's
more important for majority of academics: communication or
prestige? ...
I think there's a misconception regarding prestige and its real
significance. This issue has been raised many times recently in
discussions about OA: the frequently repeated claim, expressed
also by Eric in his blog post, is that _scholars publish for
prestige_ (and for: high metrics, tenure, "exposition", benefits,
rewards, incentives, ...) - that's why adoption of OA is slow and
costs of traditional journals are high. Do you think this claim is
true?
I don't.
The statement that "scholars publish for prestige" is an euphemism
for "scholars are careerists who care more about tenure than
quality and meaningfulness of their research". I don't believe
this. I don't believe that majority of academics are careerists
who don't care if their papers are read by anybody. Suggesting
that entire academic communication is nothing else but a PR bubble
(prestige! prestige!) driven by primitive rules of social
darwinism - is not just totally wrong, but also offending to
academia. Maybe 5% of academics are careerists, the other 95% are
extremely interested in whether their papers have _real_ impact or
not ("real" in contrast to "measured by IF"). I mean: they have a
deep _hope_ that their research will ultimately have an impact.
I'm convinced that this hope accounts for at least 90% of
motivation of those people for becoming a scientist and doing
laborious research job that's compensated with a half or 1/3 of
what's paid for similar skills outside academia.
The key problem is that prestige of the journal and size+quality
of potential audience for the paper - are correlated. Every author
who respects his own work seeks as large and reputable audience as
possible - not for prestige (!) but for the ability to communicate
own discoveries to people who are able to understand, appreciate
and make use of them. That's why authors must rely on prestiguous
journals even if prestige itself has no value for them! (BTW,
looking at the society as a whole, I think scientists are the
people with _least_ respect for prestige, compared to any other
community).
The way to change the situation is by decoupling communication
potential of journals from their perceived prestige; and by
enhancing visibility of small, niche, low-prestige journals. The
focus must be on communication, community and readers; not on
prestige.
-Marcin
--
Marcin Wojnarski, Founder and CEO, TunedIT
http://tunedit.org
http://www.facebook.com/TunedIT
http://twitter.com/wojnarski
http://www.linkedin.com/in/marcinwojnarski
TunedIT - Online Laboratory for Intelligent Algorithms
On 11/06/2012 09:58 AM, Peter Murray-Rust wrote:
Copied only to the OKFN open-access list.
It may be useful to consider the question: "what can we do to
change the situation?" - the OKF has a strong tradition of
building things to change the world. The distinction between
publishing for communication and publishing for reputation is
valuable. Maybe by changing and improving the former (which I
think OKFN is well placed to do) we can separate them.
On Tue, Nov 6, 2012 at 8:23 AM, Leslie Carr <[email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:
Publishers are capitalists - I don't think they'd argue the
point.
This is a generalization. Many learned societies and scientific
unions are not capitalists.
--
Peter Murray-Rust
Reader in Molecular Informatics
Unilever Centre, Dep. Of Chemistry
University of Cambridge
CB2 1EW, UK
+44-1223-763069 <tel:%2B44-1223-763069>
_______________________________________________
open-access mailing list
[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
http://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-access
Unsubscribe:http://lists.okfn.org/mailman/options/open-access
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
--
Marcin Wojnarski, Founder and CEO, TunedIT
http://tunedit.org
http://www.facebook.com/TunedIT
http://twitter.com/wojnarski
http://www.linkedin.com/in/marcinwojnarski
TunedIT - Online Laboratory for Intelligent Algorithms
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal