Hi Santosh
Below is the verification, if proof was needed, that the quarrel ("alleged
falsehood") you raise with my post is NOT the science, but perhaps the English
(language). Or likely your 'scientific canards' are just an attempt by you to
stand tall by standing on my shoulders and jumping on me - just another Goan
attitude.
I will respond to the outside opinion after I get the questions in the prior
posts on the expert answered. Of course, I have the right to response to your
"expert". Yet, in the interim perhaps you can write some original / innovative
posts so that Goanet readers, like me, are not getting tired with this thread.
In fact as you may know, the moderators are trying to end this thread. So
should we not try to bring this dialogue to a speedy end, instead of trying to
surreptitiously continue it under a different title? You have repeatedly
berated the moderators for showing no guts. I would like to show the
moderators some sensitivity and respect by taking their hint and heeding to
their request.
I compliment you for wanting to expose fallacies posted on Goanet, especially
the ones posted by some not in your camp. But should you not start with
yourself?
It has been alluded often, most recently by Filomena on this thread, that you
are a neurologist. Is not that false? This is especially since you do not
treat patients, (leave aside cancer patients), did not do a neurology
residency and do not have any board certification in that field. Would you not
call any reference to you as a neurologist as a gross misrepresentation of the
facts? I have never seen you correct the fact / record, when such is made. I
am not trying to demean you. Yet, once again are we being very selective in
applying 'high sounding' principles of exposing fallacies on Goanet?
Regards, GL
-------- Santosh Helekar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
The post appended below sets the record straight.
--- Mervyn Lobo <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> 1) Gilbert's original article was extremely badly written.
> 2) A board certified oncologist can make mistakes.
> 3) There are people who are capable of pointing out mistakes that a person is
> making in another profession.
_______________________________________________
Goanet mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.goanet.org/listinfo.cgi/goanet-goanet.org
