Towards the end of the scenario that Mervyn Lobo posted (vide infra), was the following:
"The QUESTION to be resolved: was the man guilty of murder, attempted murder, both?" -------RESPONSE------- My dear Mervyn, (Let us assume that this example in based in Canada or in any other major 'Common Law country) [A] : If the writer is a partially knowledgeable fictionista-patracar, award him a book prize. [B[ : If the writer is a teacher/examiner in law studies, advise him 'No trick questions at this level' [C]: If it is your lawyer who presents this scenario in court, fire him RESOLUTION based on the facts as presented by Mervyn: The Man could NOT be successfully charged for Murder or even Attempted Murder. Could be successfully charged with something else, however. good morning jc On Dec 5, 2014, at 7:32 PM, Mervyn Lobo <[email protected]> wrote: Which prompted my friend to ask me if the following was resolved: A husband and wife were having an argument on the 13th floor of their condo building. The husband told the wife to shut up else he would shoot her. The wife kept on yapping so the husband took out his gun and shot. The bullet missed the wife but went thru the window and struck a guy who was falling outside. The person falling was the couples son who had jumped off the roof after warning his parents that if they did not stop fighting, he would commit suicide. The building was going thru repairs and had a large net put up to collect falling debris. The net caught the suicide jumper and prevented his attempt but he later died in hospital from the bullet wound. The question to be resolved: was the man guilty of murder, attempted murder, both? Similarly, the technology the photo drones have, present some interesting legal challenges as to how and where one can use them. The commercial drones available today can carry much more than a conventional camera. I have the same item on my Santa wish list as you do but I am going to wait for others to sort out the laws before I use it on the ground floor of a condo unit. Mervyn
