<Topsy turvy, is a kind word. If the People had indeedaccepted Parrikar's appeals for forgiveness, they would have shown itat the voting boot.> [Gabe Menezes]
When I said the argument was topsy turvy I was referring to Dr Joe D'Souza's sequence of posing the problem at the end of his article and giving his conclusion at the beginning. You seem to have misunderstood it as a refernce to Parrikar's argument. Sorry about that.
