Eddie, Here are answers to your questions.
--- On Sun, 7/11/10, Edward Verdes <eddiever...@hotmail.com> wrote: > > You have still not answered my question why even part of my > email address which can be replied by the group members > is appearing in GX and AGD of which I am not a member? > The reason your name (not your email address) appeared on GX in that message is because someone posted that message containing your name to that forum. Neither I nor Yahoo groups can prevent a free private citizen from mentioning your name in a message to any forum, including Goanet, or ccing a message to you. > > Your point no 1 n 2..Here is a msg i just checked on GX. I > am not a memeber but still i can access it. > http://groups.yahoo.com/group/GoenchimXapotam/message/28747 > on opening the msg one can see the email ids that are in > the mail just hit on any email id links and it will ask u to sign in > your yahoo address where you can write a mail > Again you are spreading falsehoods. You have access to GX on the web because GX archives are public, just like Goanet. Nobody can see the email IDs that are in the mail. If you hit on the email id links, you are asked to sign in on that group website. You cannot sign in on that website if you are not a member of that Yahoo group. Even if you are a member, you still cannot see any of the email IDs of the members, unless you also receive emails from that group. > > Your point no 3. When I had posted on goanet with the abv subject line, >was > it not sufficient that you discuss it here instead of posting on GX >and > changing the subject line as Eddie and Noronha spreading falsehoods >on > Goanet http://groups.yahoo.com/group/GoenchimXapotam/message/28797 > No, because GXers have a right to know when someone is badmouthing their forum in another Goan forum. > >Is this not discussing me behind my back? knowing that I am not a member >of >GX? > No, because you received a cc of that post, and because GX archives are public. > > Why is it necessary to send a pvt cc when you are posting > it goanet? > Because Goanet being a heavily moderated list there is chance that the cced post might not appear on it, or appear on it only after a delay of several days. > > And finally pls tell us who created the pvt list initially? > I don't know. But certainly not me. Cheers, Santosh
