Marshall Mendonza wrote:
Fr Jerome's statement that there is no caste in Christianity is factual.

Mervyn Lobo writes:
I am based in Toronto, Canada. I am not sure where you are based but I can 
assure you that caste is a huge factor in the peculiar type of Christianity as 
practiced by Goans. Just in case, just in case you are not aware of it, here is 
a link that will update you, with every agonizing detail, how caste and 
Christianity go hand in glove in India.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste_system_among_Indian_Christians


Gilbert Lawrence responds:
 
I read the link which was kindly provided by Mervyn.  The link has nothing 
connected to what Mervyn alludes to as exist today in Goa.  The closest 
connection is:
 
"The upper caste Gaonkar Christians have demanded that only their community be 
given positions on the Pastoral Council of Goa's Catholic Church.[16]"
 
The fact that this upper caste group made the demand would suggest that they do 
not have that right.  And there is no reference that their demand has been 
accepted.
 
In the past the Bamons tended to be priests was in major part related to the 
fact that they were the only group with any education and literacy skills.  
With widespread religious affiliated schools, that problem is much resolved.
 
 
 
So do you have any CURRENT data / evidence to support,  "that caste is a huge 
factor in the peculiar type of Christianity as practiced by Goans"?   
 
 
Thanks in anticipation. Please do not take this personally.
 
 
 
Regards, GL
      • ... Santosh Helekar
      • ... Marshall Mendonza
  • ... Marshall Mendonza
    • ... Mervyn Lobo
    • ... Santosh Helekar
      • ... Santosh Helekar
  • ... Marshall Mendonza
    • ... Jose Colaco
      • ... Mervyn Lobo
    • ... Mervyn Lobo
  • ... Gilbert Lawrence
  • ... Marshall Mendonza
  • ... Frederick FN Noronha * फ्रेड्रिक नोरोन्या * فريدريك نورونيا
  • ... Marshall Mendonza
    • ... Santosh Helekar
    • ... Marshall Mendonza
  • ... Marshall Mendonza
    • ... Mervyn Lobo
  • ... Sebastian Borges
    • ... Jose Colaco
  • ... augusto pinto

Reply via email to