Hi,

> I'm not sure this is worth it, but maybe we can do better! If we were to
> prune the repo in this way, it would break `guix time-machine`, which is
> a nice selling point of Guix and really valuable.

I doubt this would cause much breakage. As long as we keep the old
repository in place existing channels.scm files would continue to
work. Sure, you can’t easily jump back into the old repository via
`guix time-machine --commit=XXX` any more, but I’ve always considered
channels.scm files the “gold standard” in terms of reproducibility.

> Anyways, there's probably some room for improvement in this area, but I
> think we should consider it out of scope for this proposal.

Agreed, a proper solution that does not require git is ouf of scope for
this GCD.

Lars


Reply via email to