Hi Mike, I think disconnected use is a MUST and not aspirational.
I would not want my networked printer to stop working, my smart appliances to not be able to read my meter, etc. all because my ISP decided to do some maintenance. Don On 3/13/13 3:28 PM, "Michael Thomas" <[email protected]> wrote: >On 03/13/2013 11:20 AM, Tim Chown wrote: >> >>> More speculation about dnydns without any motivation for why it's >>>interesting >>> and/or significant. >>> >>> There seems to be no mention of the relationship between local/home >>>resolvers >>> if the local resolver isn't the authoritative resolver. In particular, >>>it's not an >>> unusual situation to have a "cloud" (read: high bandwidth, well >>>connected...) >>> authoritative dns be a slave to a local master. Or if you don't like >>>that, some >>> other way to achieve similar goals of not wanting my home network have >>>to >>> know how to deal with ddos's on nameservers, as one for-instance. >> I think that's not precluded. The key bit is the homenet must be able >>to operate if disconnected. >> > >[i'm not a namedropper, so pardon me if I screw up nomenclature] > >I don't think we should be adopting requirements unless they are really >"hard" requirements. Disconnected use within a homenet seems more >aspirational than hard -- there are just so many things that will puke if >the net is down, that I don't think we should worry about it. > >That said, there seems to be an assumption that the CER would be the >logical place to house a repository. I don't recall seeing any discussion >about whether it would be what the root resolvers points to. If it is, >we definitely have to think about bandwidth, DoS, etc, etc. If it's not >the preferred means (which i don't really think it is because if nothing >else, you need failover resolvers), I think we need to flesh this out a >bit >more to say that, so that we can take inventory of whether the CER could >reasonably master for a cloud-based slave. Or something else... I'm not >wedded to a solution, just want to see more clarity about the problem >space. > >Mike >_______________________________________________ >homenet mailing list >[email protected] >https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet _______________________________________________ homenet mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet
