On 6/16/16 2:48 PM, Ralph Droms wrote:
On Jun 16, 2016, at 1:26 PM 6/16/16, Ray Bellis <r...@isc.org> wrote:
As was alluded to in my email of 9th June, we have been asked to replace
RFC 7788 (HNCP) with an RFC 7788-bis as soon as possible to incorporate
the errata raised by the DNSOP chair regarding the unintended apparent
reservation of ".home" as the default domain TLV within HNCP.
We should also take that opportunity to fix the error in the diagrams
for the DHCPv4_DATA and DHCPv6_DATA TLVs where the numbers shown
conflict with the IANA registrations for those TLVs.
Those two changes will be the only ones made, unless any further errata
are made in the meantime.
Slightly longer term, and notwithstanding our previously stated desire
to wait until Ted Lemon's Naming Architecture was further progressed, we
would like to obtain WG consensus on whether ".home" is indeed a
suitable default domain for HNCP. In the meantime, implementors are
hereby advised that ".home" is potentially subject to change.
In my opinion, it is important for the exact requirements and semantics for the
default domain be defined, perhaps even before the default domain itself is
selected. It's not clear to me whether the domain carried in the Domain-Name
TLV can be a delegated domain or it has to be a special use domain name for
location-relative name resolution like .local, or if either type of name is OK.
- Ralph
+1 on this.
tim
_______________________________________________
homenet mailing list
homenet@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet
