On Nov 19, 2009, at 10:00 AM, [email protected] wrote:

> To paraphrase a famous quote, all a Horn is, is a series of tubes.

That is true, but that is not what is in question here. That statement  
is so general and limited it makes it worthless. The only way you  
could make a horn in tune would be to have a different tube for each  
note, sort of like an organ. But even organs are not "perfectly in  
tune." And really, this discussion has little to do with just or equal  
temperament.
>
> The lips aren't a perfect frequency generator - and this is why the  
> pitch
> can sag/rise when we play on a harmonic. However, if we were to put  
> in a set
> of  robotic lips (akin to what Honda/Toyota has done with a few of  
> their
> robots) we  notice that the harmonics are rock solid, very  
> consistent, and all
> you need is  to change the length of the tubing.

Uh, I don't think so. Only in a world where the tone quality of the  
horn would be missing. Those aren't the kind of tubes we want in a  
horn. What about the air stream? Notes sag more often from air issues  
than embouchure issues. What about the fact that you cannot tune a  
horn to play in tune on every note? What about hand position? What  
about the fact that any fingering using more than one valve is going  
to be sharp? That alone shoots down your whole theory.
>
> You want to have as good an embouchure as possible, yes. And if a  
> Horn is
> properly tuned it is the player's fault for being out of tune due to  
> an
> imperfect embouchure - so you bring the horn as close as you can to  
> being in
> tune.

Absolutely false. The embouchure has a lot to do with it, but the air  
factors and hand position are even more important. I'm afraid you need  
to dig a little deeper. The horn, as designed for the tone qualities  
that are desired CANNOT be tuned "perfectly."

>
> A specific tube of a specific length has a very specific and  
> measurable
> Harmonic frequency. Whether our lips match it or not is a different  
> story.

So what? We don't have a tube for every note. We are talking about a  
harmonic series that is not totally in tune with itself. The horn is  
NOT just a bunch of tubes. The "lip match" thing is off target and  
irrelevant in the Real World of Horn Playing.

>
> Long tones also help build up that 'imperfect' embouchure too.

You seem to be fixated on embouchures. There is more to it than that.  
There is no way to tune any horn perfectly for all notes, "perfect  
embouchure" or not. Long tones or not.
>
> Then again - I'm only going by what the Physics papers tell me with  
> regards
> to intonation and harmonics - and by what's demonstrable with  
> robotics.

Well, there you have it.  We are not robots, the horn is not a normal  
tube and the harmonic series on a horn is not in tune and it varies  
from horn to horn because of design differences and tapers. All  
fingerings of more than one valve are going to be sharp. Bad hand  
positions effect intonation differently on each horn of the double  
horn. Need anything else?

>
> -William


OK, now I have heard just about everything, I think. NO, thats not  
right, but still, you go to the ballpark every day and you will see  
something new. The two Cs that started this discussion can be set to  
be "in tune" for our purposes. That is a fact. That is one of the  
choices we make when tuning the horn. Other choices are more  
difficult, but in the end, we learn to play the horn in tune because  
we want to and we work at it.

Sincerely,
Wendell
For info about my book, DVDs and live video chat horn lessons, see my  
web site at www.wendellworld.com



_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to