2009/11/19 <[email protected]>: > Perhaps my communication is not clear. > > I never said every note would be perfectly in tune with equal temperament. > > What I did say is that the n^2 harmonics should always be in tune with the > nth fundamental. > > Certain harmonics are SUPPOSED to be flat or sharp - I'm pretty sure I said > this.
I think Wendell's point was that no horn actually produces an absolutely perfect harmonic sequence. There are too many compromises in the design with conical and cylindrical sections of tubing, and the need to design and build the horn for tone quality as well as tuning. It's close, but not quite perfect. And embouchure, airstream and hand position all also have an effect - each of which varies with register in their different ways. Those effects are sufficient to render the 2 cents worth of variation between true harmonic and the equivalent equal temperament in the 6th partial as being trivial and almost undetectable. I completely agree with you that there is a mathematical difference between the integer frequency ratios that give you just intonation and the twelfth root ratios of equal temperament. I've looked into that differences in some detail. The practical effect of these differences is that you don't just tune the horn and then play it. You look out for the tuning of each individual note and adjust it to fit. You have to, because of the tuning compromises of the instrument itself, and because of the tuning variabilities of the other instruments in the ensemble (they all have their tuning oddities resulting from compromises is design and manufacture) and the variations that come from people naturally hearing just intonation in the current key and wanting to eliminate "beats". Regards Jonathan West _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
