First paragraph: The horn is for all intents a purposes a normal tube - tapers do not effect the standing wave frequencies. As for the rest - I said that as well but maybe my communication sucks today? Second paragraph: You can set the two C's in tune, but why would you? 6th partial is not supposed to be in tune. It's naturally sharp. If you tune 6th partial to be in tune it lowers everything else to be flat - giving you flat 8th partials (ew) and even flatter 5th partials (which are already bad enough). I've given the math why this is the case - and I've given the math as to why tapers/shape of the tubing will not effect standing wave frequencies. Like I said, if there are any peer-reviewed research papers which show the shape of a tube to change the standing wave frequencies of a tube/cone to be anything but n^2 from the base fundamental frequency n, then by all means show me the papers. We do agree on a lot - but I'm not sure my communication is clear enough for you this to be apparent. -William In a message dated 11/19/2009 4:19:12 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, [email protected] writes:
Well, there you have it. We are not robots, the horn is not a normal tube and the harmonic series on a horn is not in tune and it varies from horn to horn because of design differences and tapers. All fingerings of more than one valve are going to be sharp. Bad hand positions effect intonation differently on each horn of the double horn. Need anything else? > > -William OK, now I have heard just about everything, I think. NO, thats not right, but still, you go to the ballpark every day and you will see something new. The two Cs that started this discussion can be set to be "in tune" for our purposes. That is a fact. That is one of the choices we make when tuning the horn. Other choices are more difficult, but in the end, we learn to play the horn in tune because we want to and we work at it. _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
