Well, I would strongly disagree.  Of course playing music IS spiritual 
and/or religious or whatever other term you would prefer for expressing the 
inexpressible.  Otherwise, why would we bother to do it?  For the joy of 
reproducing some notes in a mechanical fashion?  Well, some people get some 
thrill out of that sort of thing.  The music that transports me to the other 
dimension doesn't just speak to my brain, it speaks to my whole body, my soul 
and to every unexplained particle in the universe.  I can appreciate the 
fountain too, but it's the fairies that make it worthwhile.  This is not to 
insult the human brain, but the brain is so much more than a bucket full of 
cells with a current running though it.  That's just zombie food.  If your 
music is only controlled by your brain, you're just scratching about 10 feet 
above the surface.  The mind IS infinite and it does not obey the laws of 
physics as currently understood. 
    BTW, I had occasion to own, for a short while, a reproducing grand piano 
made in the 1930s.  Like a player piano, but it also reproduces dynamics, 
pedaling, touch etc.  About as realistic as you can get to a live performance.  
I believe there's a recording out there of Percy Grainger playing the Grieg 
Piano Concerto (recorded long ago on reproducing piano) with a modern live 
orchestra.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

William wrote:

Keep your opinions to yourself, especially if they are offensive and 
rude.

Stick to the facts, please.

I'm sorry, but I don't 
feel there is anything spiritual or religious about anything we do. It 
can be measured. It can be reproduced. To see the human mind for what it
 is is in no way degrading what it can do or insulting it. To paraphrase
 Richard Dawkins, I can appreciate the fountain in a garden without 
thinking that there are fairies at the bottom of it.

The human 
mind, although powerful, is not infinite. It has to obey the laws of 
physics just like everything else. 

 -William
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to