I like the idea of applying the Turing test to robotic music, though 
this may make some composers nervous.  I have read that there are poetry 
writing programs that can produce poems readily taken for human-made.  
It would not surprise me to learn that there are already composing 
programs that could pass the test, or come close to it.  But what then?  
Humans have always been capable of producing gibberish, and there are 
other humans who will claim to see or hear profound truth in it.  So 
where does this leave us?  I do what I do as a composer because that's 
what I love to do.  If I could do it all with a machine, I wouldn't bother.

As for playing the horn, it is the triumph of the brain and body in 
overcoming an intractable brass tube and the often unfriendly laws of 
physics.     Here in Seattle, the NW Mahler Festival is preparing 
Mahler's Seventh for a concert next Sunday.  As I sit there in the 
rehearsals,  I get a shot of adrenaline in anticipation of the horn 
solos at the beginning of the second movement.  This happens every time 
even though I am not playing.   It would never happen in a robot 
performance.  And would we watch the World Cup if it could somehow be 
played by robots?

David Lamb in Seattle

_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to